Does an HOA need workers' compensation insurance?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised September 22, 2026

When an HOA has to carry workers' comp, why state thresholds differ, how an uninsured contractor becomes the association's employee, and where volunteers stand.

The question is whether the association employs anyone, and that word is broader than boards think

Workers' compensation obligations attach to employers, so the first job is deciding whether your association is one. State definitions of employee generally turn on performing service for another under a contract of hire, express or implied, written or oral. That language catches more people than a board expects. The obvious cases are an on-site manager, a maintenance technician and a seasonal pool attendant. The less obvious ones are where the trouble lives: the gate attendant paid weekly from petty cash, an owner's teenager paid to mow the entrance island, the retired resident who takes a monthly stipend to handle work orders. Paying someone in cash, calling them a contractor in the minutes, or handing them a 1099 does not decide the question. The relationship decides it. When a board gets this wrong, the correction usually arrives as an injury claim, which is the worst possible moment to learn that your handyman was an employee.

The thresholds are genuinely different from state to state

There is no national rule, and the spread between states is wide enough that advice from a board member who moved in from somewhere else is often useless. California requires every employer to secure the payment of compensation under Labor Code section 3700, either by buying insurance or by obtaining a certificate of consent to self-insure. No small-employer exemption applies, so the first paid employee triggers it, and failing to secure coverage is a crime under section 3700.5, punishable by up to a year in county jail and a fine starting at ten thousand dollars. Florida sets a headcount instead: under Florida Statutes section 440.02(20)(b), covered private employment means four or more employees for most employers and one or more in the construction industry. Texas is the outlier that trips people up most. Coverage is elective for most private employers under Labor Code section 406.002, so a Texas association can lawfully go without it. What it cannot do is go without consequences. Under section 406.033(a), a nonsubscribing employer sued by an injured employee may not defend on contributory negligence, assumption of risk, or the negligence of a fellow employee. Declining coverage in Texas trades a capped statutory system for an uncapped negligence suit with three defenses removed.

The uninsured contractor is the bigger exposure, and most boards never see it coming

An association with no payroll at all can still end up on the hook, because hiring a contractor who carries no coverage can make that contractor's crew your problem. Florida is explicit: under section 440.10(1)(b), employees of a contractor and of its subcontractors on the same contract work are deemed employed in one and the same business, except where a subcontractor has secured its own coverage, so the party above an uninsured sub absorbs the liability. Section 440.10(1)(c) supplies the defense, and it is simply requiring evidence of coverage before the work starts. California arrives at a similar place by a different route. Labor Code section 2750.5 creates a presumption that a worker is an employee, and its final paragraph conditions independent contractor status on holding a valid contractor's license where the work requires one. The unlicensed handyman who falls off your clubhouse roof is, on that presumption, the association's employee. This is the concrete reason behind the certificate requirement that sounds like paperwork until the day it is not, and our guide on whether an HOA can require your contractor to be licensed and insured goes further into what to collect and verify.

Volunteers, directors, and the exemptions that do not fit an association

Unpaid board members are generally not employees, because there is no hire and no wage, and directors serving without compensation ordinarily sit outside the workers' compensation system. Two things blur that line. Compensation creeps in quietly, as a stipend, a waived assessment or a gift card at the holiday meeting. And the community workday, where a dozen owners spend a Saturday spreading mulch and one of them falls, is a genuinely unsettled situation that most boards have never raised with their agent. Some states permit an employer to elect coverage for volunteers, and where that option exists it is worth pricing. Do not reach for the household exemptions to solve this. California Labor Code section 3351(d) and the 52 hour, one hundred dollar test at section 3352(a)(8) are built around a person employed by the owner or occupant of a residential dwelling for duties incidental to that dwelling. An association hiring someone to maintain common property it owns as a corporation is not that employer, and a board that assumes the household carve-out covers it has assumed away its exposure instead of checking it.

No other policy in the stack fills this gap

Boards reason that between the master policy, general liability and directors and officers coverage, an injured worker must be covered by something. Usually not. Commercial general liability policies exclude bodily injury to an employee arising out of employment, precisely because workers' compensation is meant to handle it. Directors and officers coverage responds to wrongful acts in managing the association, not to a broken leg. An umbrella follows the exclusions in the policies beneath it. That leaves an uninsured association facing the claim directly, out of operating funds and reserves, and then facing the owners when the shortfall becomes a special assessment. If your community is still working out what its coverage should include, our guide on whether an HOA has to have insurance lays out the core policies and where each requirement comes from.

What a board should do this quarter

Start with the ledger, not with opinions. List everyone paid from the operating account in the last twelve months and mark which ones performed labor rather than delivering goods. Give that list to your insurance agent and ask, in writing, whether your state's definition makes any of them an employee and whether current coverage responds. A written answer from an agent is worth more at claim time than a recollection of a phone call. Collect current workers' compensation certificates from every contractor, name the association as certificate holder so you are notified on cancellation, and ask about a waiver of subrogation. Then calendar the renewal dates, because the common failure is not a vendor who never had coverage, it is a vendor whose policy lapsed in month seven of a twelve month contract. If the community uses a management company, confirm in the agreement whose employees the on-site staff legally are, since co-employment questions tend to surface only after an injury. Thresholds, penalties and contractor liability rules are state specific and they change, so confirm your situation with your association's insurance agent and attorney rather than relying on any general summary.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More on dues & money

Or browse all hoa dues, fees & money guides.