Should our HOA offer a discount to owners who pay a full year of dues up front?
By OurHOA · General information · Revised
Should an HOA give owners a discount for paying annual dues up front? The math, what the declaration allows, budgeting, home sales mid-year and sample notice wording.
Part of the HOA board handbook: treasurer and money.
The short answer
Let owners pay the year up front if they want to. Think hard before attaching a discount to it. A 1 or 2 percent discount sounds cheap, but it comes straight out of revenue the budget was counting on, and the interest the association earns on the early cash rarely covers it. Where a discount makes sense is a community with a chronic late-payment problem, where getting a third of the owners paid in January saves the treasurer real collection work. If you do offer one, decide it before the budget is adopted, budget the cost as its own line, check that your declaration allows it, and offer it to every owner on the same terms. Rules vary by state and by your governing documents. This is general education, not legal advice.
Run the numbers before you vote
Take a 90-home community with dues of $250 a month, or $3,000 a year. The board considers a 2 percent discount for anyone who pays the full year by January 31. The discount is $60 per owner. If 30 owners take it, the association gives up $1,800 of assessment revenue. Those 30 owners send in $2,940 each, about $88,200 in January. That cash would have arrived over 12 months anyway, so the extra money in the bank shrinks every month as the association spends it. On average over the year the association holds roughly $40,000 more than it otherwise would. If that money sits in an account earning 4 percent, it earns about $1,600. At 1 percent, about $400. So at best the discount roughly breaks even on interest. The rest of the case has to come from fewer late payments, fewer reminder letters and fewer card or processing fees. Ask the treasurer how many owners were late last year and what chasing them cost in time and postage. If the answer is 'almost nobody', skip the discount. If it is a dozen owners every quarter, a discount may pay for itself. Use your own rates and your own numbers. Do not assume anything about participation; ask owners in a one-question survey before the budget meeting.
Check the declaration first
A discount means some owners pay less than others for the same share of common expenses. Whether that fits your documents is the first question. Florida section 720.308(1)(a), which covers communities created after October 1, 1995, says assessments must be in each member's proportional share of expenses as described in the governing documents. Colorado section 38-33.3-315(2) says common expenses are assessed against all units according to the allocations in the declaration, and section 38-33.3-315(1) requires assessments at least annually, based on a budget adopted at least annually. Texas has no statute on prepayment discounts, so the declaration and bylaws decide; note that a Texas resale certificate under Property Code section 207.003(b)(2) must state the frequency and amount of regular assessments, so whatever you adopt should be written clearly enough to report. Read three places: the assessment article of the declaration, which sets the allocation and the payment schedule; the bylaws, for the board's power to set due dates; and any existing collection policy. Many declarations let the board set the payment schedule, which supports offering an annual option. Fewer say anything about discounts. If the language is unclear, ask the association's attorney before you put a discount in the budget, because unwinding one mid-year is awkward. Our guide on whether an HOA can make you prepay dues covers the owner's side: the board can offer annual payment, but it cannot force it on owners who pay on the normal schedule.
Budget and bookkeeping
Budget the discount as its own line. If revenue is 90 homes times $3,000, or $270,000, and you expect 30 owners to take a 2 percent discount, show $1,800 in discounts so the net revenue figure is honest. Otherwise the shortfall comes out of the reserve contribution or the maintenance line by accident. Record the January money correctly. An owner who pays the whole year on January 20 has paid for February through December in advance. On accrual books, the unearned months are a liability, usually called prepaid assessments, and the treasurer moves one month into income each month. On cash-basis books, at least note the prepaid amount on each monthly report so the board does not read a fat January balance as a surplus. Do not spend the extra cash in the first quarter. It is the money that pays the second half of the year's bills. Watch deposit insurance. FDIC insurance covers $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, for each account ownership category. A large community that collects a year of dues from many owners in one month can cross that line in its operating account. Spread funds across banks or move part into an insured account elsewhere until it is needed.
When an owner sells or the dues change mid-year
A prepaid owner who sells in June has paid through December. Write down in the policy what happens. In most sales the title company prorates prepaid assessments between seller and buyer at closing, so the association keeps the money and simply records the new owner as paid through December. Do not promise refunds of the discount; it was a price for paying early, and it stays earned. The association's closing statement has to show the prepayment correctly. In Texas, the resale certificate under section 207.003(b)(4) states the total of amounts due and unpaid. In Florida, the estoppel certificate under section 720.30851(1)(h) states the date through which the regular periodic assessment is paid. In Colorado, section 38-33.3-316(8) requires a written statement of unpaid assessments within 14 calendar days of a proper request, and that statement binds the association. A prepaid account that shows as past due on one of those documents causes problems at closing and can bind the association to the wrong number. State in the notice that the discount applies only to the regular assessment in the adopted budget. A special assessment approved later in the year, or a mid-year budget correction, is billed separately to everyone, including owners who prepaid.
Notice wording and a motion
Put the offer in the budget mailing so owners see it with the new dues amount. Sample notice paragraph: Owners may pay the full 2027 regular assessment of $3,000 in one payment. Payments of $2,940 received by January 31, 2027 will be accepted as payment in full for the year, a 2 percent discount. To qualify, the account must have no past-due balance on the date of payment. Payments received after January 31 do not qualify, and the monthly schedule of $250 due on the first of each month applies. The discount does not apply to any special assessment. If you sell your home during the year, prepaid assessments are handled at closing between you and the buyer; the association does not refund the discount. Motion: Moved to offer owners a 2 percent discount on the 2027 regular assessment for full payment received by January 31, 2027, available to all owners whose accounts are current on the date of payment, with the expected cost of $1,800 shown as a separate line in the 2027 budget. Keep the deadline firm. A treasurer who accepts the discounted amount on February 10 for one owner has to do it for everyone.
Mistakes boards make
Adopting the discount after the budget, so the cost comes out of reserves without anyone deciding that it should. Offering it to some owners and not others, or letting directors take it after the deadline. Treating the January deposit as income for the month and approving a project on the strength of it. Leaving the prepaid owner's account looking past due because the accounting system expects monthly payments. Set the account up as paid through December on the day the money arrives. Picking a discount large enough to matter, 5 percent or more, without checking that the budget can absorb it if half the community signs up. Assuming owners who prepay will never be late. If one bounces a $2,940 check, our guide on handling a bounced HOA dues payment covers the steps.
Sources
These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.
More from the board handbook
- How can an HOA protect its bank accounts from payment fraud?
- What does an HOA treasurer need to do every month and quarter?
- What does a new HOA treasurer need from the previous treasurer?
- What is the timeline for an HOA board collecting past-due dues?
- How does an HOA switch from paper checks to online dues payments?
- How does an HOA board get its books ready for the CPA at year end?
- How should a small HOA budget for rising insurance premiums?
- How does an HOA board answer a resale certificate or estoppel request on deadline?
- How do we move our HOA's bank accounts to a new bank without missing payments?
- How does an HOA protest the property tax appraisal on its common area?
- How should an HOA board budget for legal fees?
- What does an HOA board do when an owner files bankruptcy?
- How do we get a bank loan for an HOA project?
- How do we hire a CPA firm for our HOA's annual review or audit?
- What should the HOA treasurer do when an owner's dues payment bounces?
- How do we hire a bookkeeper or accounting service for our HOA?
- How should our HOA board respond to an IRS notice or penalty letter?
- How does an HOA file a claim against a deceased owner's estate?
- How do we set up a bank lockbox or remote deposit for HOA dues checks?
- What should an HOA board do when the bank freezes or restricts the association's account?
- How do we apply for a city or county neighborhood grant for an HOA project?
- How do we hire a collection agency for unpaid HOA dues?
- How does our HOA board fill out a condo lender questionnaire?
- How does an HOA collect unpaid dues after a lender forecloses on a home?
- How do we dispute a high master-metered water bill with the utility?
- How do we set up an audit committee of owners to check the HOA's books?
- How should an HOA board respond when an owner demands a forensic audit?
- How do we fix a mistake in the HOA budget after the board adopted it?
- How should an HOA treasurer handle an owner who pays dues in cash?
- What should an HOA board do in the first 48 hours after association checks or a debit card are stolen?
- An owner disputed their HOA dues card payment with their bank. What should the treasurer do?
- An owner says they paid HOA dues but we have no record of it. What should the treasurer do?
- How should an HOA board handle owner requests to waive late fees?
- How do we set up an expense reimbursement or petty cash policy for our HOA?
- How do we file an unclaimed property report for uncashed HOA checks and old credit balances?
- An owner paid HOA dues to a former manager or an old bank account. How do we get the money back?
- What should an HOA board do when the treasurer will be out for months?
- What should our HOA board do when the utility sends a disconnection notice for the association's own account?
- How does an HOA reconcile its bank statement?
- Does an HOA need an EIN?
- Should an HOA use cash or accrual accounting?
- Does an HOA check need two signatures?
- Does an HOA have to keep reserve funds in a separate bank account?