How should our HOA board respond to the findings in our CPA's audit or review?
By OurHOA · General information · Revised
What an HOA board does after the CPA's audit or review: read the report and internal control letter, adopt a written response, fix findings and share the report on time.
Part of the HOA board handbook: treasurer and money.
The short answer
When the accountant finishes, the board usually gets two things: the report on the financial statements, and, after an audit, a letter describing weaknesses the accountant found in how money is handled. Read both at a board meeting, not just the treasurer. Write down a response to every item in the letter: what you will change, who does it and by when. Send the report to owners within your state's deadline, then check the fixes before the accountant comes back next year. Most boards file the package and move on. That is how the same finding shows up three years running, and how a small control gap turns into missing money. Rules on reporting levels and distribution vary by state and by your governing documents, so treat this as education, not legal advice.
Know what the report is telling you
Start with what kind of work you paid for, because the report means very different things. The AICPA describes the three levels this way: in a compilation the CPA provides no assurance, in a review the CPA aims for limited assurance that the statements are free of material misstatement, and in an audit the CPA obtains high, but not absolute, assurance. A review report that raises no issues does not mean anyone tested your bank balances. For an audit, read the opinion paragraph first. A clean opinion says the statements present fairly the association's financial position in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles. Colorado's turnover rule, section 38-33.3-303(9)(b), uses that same language and names the alternative: a disclaimer, where the accountant says it cannot attest to the statements. If your opinion paragraph adds an exception, or the accountant declines to give an opinion, the board needs a written explanation from the firm and a plan before the report goes to owners. Then read the notes. They hold the reserve balances, commitments, uncollected assessments and anything the accountant thought owners should know. A treasurer who has never read the notes is reading half the report.
How to read the internal control letter
An auditor who finds serious control problems puts them in writing to the board. The sample letter the North Carolina Department of State Treasurer gives local auditors uses the standard definitions. A deficiency exists when the design or operation of a control does not let people, in their normal duties, prevent or detect and correct misstatements on a timely basis. A material weakness is a deficiency, or a combination of them, that creates a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement will not be prevented or caught in time. A significant deficiency is less severe than a material weakness yet important enough to merit attention by those charged with governance. For an HOA, those charged with governance are the board. Two lines in these letters get skipped. First, the audit was not designed to give an opinion on internal control, so a short letter, or none, is not a clean bill of health. Second, many letters list significant audit adjustments: corrections the accountant made that, in its judgment, your own process would not have caught. Each adjustment is a finding even if the letter does not call it one. In a 60-home association, the usual items are the ones on North Carolina's list of examples: one person handles every step of a process (no segregation of duties), accounts are not reconciled on time, or nobody checks the person who does the books.
Write a response for every item
Make a one-page worksheet with five columns: the finding in the accountant's words, the board's response, the person responsible, the deadline, and the proof that it is done. The response is one of three things. 1. Fix it. Example: the treasurer writes checks and reconciles the account. Response: a second director receives the bank statement directly from the bank, reviews it each month and initials the reconciliation. 2. Add a compensating control when a full fix is impossible. With five volunteers you cannot split every duty, but a director who is not a signer can review every payment over $1,000 each month. 3. Accept the risk, in writing, with a reason. This should be rare, and the minutes should show the board chose it. Keep the director whose work is criticized out of writing the response alone. That person knows the process best, so ask for a draft, but the board adopts the final version. Our guide on the HOA treasurer monthly checklist lists the routine reviews that close most of these findings.
Wording you can use
A motion for the minutes: "I move that the board accept the [reviewed / audited] financial statements for the fiscal year ended [date] as prepared by [firm], adopt the attached response to the accountant's letter on internal control, and direct the treasurer to report progress on each item at the [month] board meeting." A response paragraph for one finding, which you can send back to the firm: "The board agrees with this finding. Beginning [month], the bank will mail monthly statements for the operating and reserve accounts to [director], who is not a check signer. That director will compare the statement to the treasurer's reconciliation, initial both and report any difference to the board within 10 days. The board will review compliance quarterly." Specific names, dates and dollar amounts make a response you can check. "The board will improve oversight" cannot be checked.
Share the report on time
Florida HOAs follow section 720.303(7). The association must complete the annual financial report within 90 days after the fiscal year ends, or on the date in the bylaws. Within 21 days after the final report is received from the accountant, and no later than 120 days after year end or the bylaw date, each member must get a copy or a written notice that a copy is available free on request. Revenue sets the level: compiled statements from $150,000, reviewed from $300,000, audited from $500,000 or for 1,000 or more parcels. In Colorado, section 38-33.3-303(4)(b) lets the board order an audit or review, and owners of one-third of the units can require a review, or an audit once revenues or expenditures reach $250,000. Copies must be available to any owner on request no later than 30 days after completion. Texas Property Code chapter 209 does not set a reporting level. Section 209.005(c) opens the association's books and records, including financial records, to owners, and section 209.005(m)(6) requires associations with more than 14 lots to keep tax returns and audit records for seven years. In California, Civil Code section 5305 requires a review by a licensee once gross income exceeds $75,000, delivered to members within 120 days after year end. Write the board's response as if owners will read it, because in many states they can ask for it.
A sample calendar
For a calendar-year association using a review or audit: - February: the treasurer sends the year-end package to the firm. - March: the firm sends a draft. The treasurer and one other director read it and send questions within 10 days. Fix wording and number errors before the report is final, not after. - Within two weeks of the final report: a board meeting adopts the motion and the response worksheet. - By April 30 (120 days) in Florida, or your state's deadline: owners get the report or notice. - June and September board meetings: the treasurer reports each open item as done, late or changed. - November: send the firm the completed worksheet with this year's engagement letter, so fieldwork can test the fixes. Shift the months if your fiscal year ends in June. The order stays the same.
Mistakes boards make
The first is reading only the totals. The internal control letter, not the balance sheet, is where the accountant tells you what could go wrong next year. The second is arguing over wording. If the firm wrote that reconciliations were late and they were, agree and fix it. The third is letting a repeat finding slide. A finding that appears two years in a row tells owners, lenders and insurers the board did not act. Track every item until it closes. The fourth is treating a review as an audit and telling owners the books were audited. They were not, and the difference matters if something goes wrong. The last is leaving the work with the treasurer. If your board has an audit committee, give it the worksheet. Our guide on setting up an HOA audit committee explains how that committee checks the books between visits from the accountant.
Sources
- AICPA & CIMA: What is the difference among a compilation, review and audit?
- North Carolina Department of State Treasurer: sample AU-C 265 letter on significant deficiencies and material weaknesses
- North Carolina Department of State Treasurer: examples of deficiencies, significant deficiencies and material weaknesses
- Florida Statutes 720.303: association records and financial reporting
- Colorado Revised Statutes title 38, section 38-33.3-303: executive board, audits and reviews
- Texas Property Code chapter 209, section 209.005: association records
- California Civil Code section 5305: review of financial statements
These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.
More from the board handbook
- How can an HOA protect its bank accounts from payment fraud?
- What does an HOA treasurer need to do every month and quarter?
- What does a new HOA treasurer need from the previous treasurer?
- What is the timeline for an HOA board collecting past-due dues?
- How does an HOA switch from paper checks to online dues payments?
- How does an HOA board get its books ready for the CPA at year end?
- How should a small HOA budget for rising insurance premiums?
- How does an HOA board answer a resale certificate or estoppel request on deadline?
- How do we move our HOA's bank accounts to a new bank without missing payments?
- How does an HOA protest the property tax appraisal on its common area?
- How should an HOA board budget for legal fees?
- What does an HOA board do when an owner files bankruptcy?
- How do we get a bank loan for an HOA project?
- How do we hire a CPA firm for our HOA's annual review or audit?
- What should the HOA treasurer do when an owner's dues payment bounces?
- How do we hire a bookkeeper or accounting service for our HOA?
- How should our HOA board respond to an IRS notice or penalty letter?
- How does an HOA file a claim against a deceased owner's estate?
- How do we set up a bank lockbox or remote deposit for HOA dues checks?
- What should an HOA board do when the bank freezes or restricts the association's account?
- How do we apply for a city or county neighborhood grant for an HOA project?
- How do we hire a collection agency for unpaid HOA dues?
- How does our HOA board fill out a condo lender questionnaire?
- How does an HOA collect unpaid dues after a lender forecloses on a home?
- How do we dispute a high master-metered water bill with the utility?
- How do we set up an audit committee of owners to check the HOA's books?
- How should an HOA board respond when an owner demands a forensic audit?
- How do we fix a mistake in the HOA budget after the board adopted it?
- How should an HOA treasurer handle an owner who pays dues in cash?
- What should an HOA board do in the first 48 hours after association checks or a debit card are stolen?
- An owner disputed their HOA dues card payment with their bank. What should the treasurer do?
- An owner says they paid HOA dues but we have no record of it. What should the treasurer do?
- How should an HOA board handle owner requests to waive late fees?
- How do we set up an expense reimbursement or petty cash policy for our HOA?
- Should our HOA offer a discount to owners who pay a full year of dues up front?
- How do we file an unclaimed property report for uncashed HOA checks and old credit balances?
- An owner paid HOA dues to a former manager or an old bank account. How do we get the money back?
- What should an HOA board do when the treasurer will be out for months?
- What should our HOA board do when the utility sends a disconnection notice for the association's own account?
- When should an HOA board write off dues it cannot collect?
- How do we send the annual HOA dues invoice to every owner?
- How does an HOA board levy a special assessment, step by step?
- What should our HOA board do when one of its own directors is behind on dues?
- Does our HOA have to collect sales tax on guest passes, amenity fees and clubhouse rentals?
- Can our HOA treasurer prepare and file Form 1120-H without a CPA?
- Our HOA bought a home at its own foreclosure sale. What does the board do with it now?
- How do we write and run an HOA payment plan policy?
- How does an HOA board levy an insurance deductible assessment after a loss?
- Our HOA won a court judgment against an owner. How do we actually collect it?
- How should an HOA board handle owner payments after an account goes to the attorney?
- A home sold and the closing didn't pay everything owed to the HOA. How do we collect from the former owner?
- What should our HOA board do when a lot in the community is headed to a property tax sale?
- How do we collect HOA dues on a lot owned by an LLC that the state dissolved or forfeited?
- Owners want to pay HOA dues by Zelle or Venmo. Should the board allow it, and how do we set it up?
- How should our HOA board budget for electric, water and sewer costs?
- Who should pick up our HOA's mail, and how should we handle the checks that come in?
- How do we set up a process for approving and paying HOA bills?
- How do we choose a bank for our HOA's accounts?
- How should our HOA store blank checks, track voided checks and control the checkbook?
- A vendor asks our HOA to pay in cash. What should the board do?
- How do we run a mid-year review of the HOA budget and forecast where the year will end?
- How does our HOA board fill out a W-9 when a bank, insurer or tenant asks for one?
- Can our HOA board change dues from one annual payment to monthly or quarterly payments?
- How do we borrow from HOA reserves to cover an operating shortfall, and how do we pay it back?
- How should our HOA board bill builders for assessments on the lots they own?
- Our reserve study says the HOA is badly underfunded. How do we catch up without a huge special assessment?
- How does a Florida HOA board demand rent from a tenant when the owner is behind on dues?
- How does an HOA apply for an SBA disaster loan to repair common area damage?
- How do we invest our HOA reserve funds in CDs or Treasury bills?
- Our HOA's bank is being bought by another bank. What does the treasurer need to do?
- We are hiring our first HOA employee. How does the treasurer set up payroll?
- What should go in the treasurer's report at an HOA board meeting?
- How does an HOA board file a small claims case for unpaid dues?
- What should our HOA do when a vendor won't give us a W-9?
- How does an HOA board run the meeting where it adopts next year's budget?
- How do we e-file our HOA's 1099s through the IRS IRIS portal?
- Does our HOA have to file a beneficial ownership (BOI) report with FinCEN?
- How do we write an HOA collection policy for past-due dues?
- Our HOA has not filed tax returns for years. How does the board catch up?
- How do we record an HOA lien for unpaid dues and release it after payment?
- An owner on active duty sent us orders. How do we apply the 6 percent SCRA cap to their HOA account?
- A court entered a money judgment against our HOA. How does the board pay it?
- What should an HOA board do when owners vote down the budget or a dues increase?
- Should our HOA be paying the sales tax on vendor invoices and utility bills?
- Our HOA's common area is headed to a property tax sale, or already sold. What should the board do?
- We think our HOA treasurer took association money. What should the board do?
- Our HOA's financial records are missing. How do we rebuild the books?
- Should our HOA accept a deed in lieu from an owner who can't pay dues?
- Our HOA has billed the wrong assessment shares for years. How do we fix it?
- How do we set up a finance or budget committee for our HOA?
- How do we get HOA money out of a board member's personal bank account?
- Our HOA got an IRS levy or a writ of garnishment for money we owe a vendor. What does the board do?
- Can our HOA get a credit or exemption on the city stormwater or drainage fee for the pond we maintain?
- What should an HOA treasurer do with an owner's check marked paid in full for less than the balance?
- How do we appoint an owner as assistant treasurer to help with the HOA's books?
- Our bank says it is closing the HOA's account. What should the board do?
- How does an HOA reconcile its bank statement?
- Does an HOA need an EIN?
- Should an HOA use cash or accrual accounting?
- Does an HOA check need two signatures?
- Does an HOA have to keep reserve funds in a separate bank account?
More on dues & money
- How can our HOA board thank volunteers without paying them?
- What should an HOA board do when a board member is arrested or charged with a crime?
- Someone recorded a fake lien against HOA property or a director's home. How does the board get it removed?
Or browse all hoa dues, fees & money guides.