OurHOA
Dues & money

Someone recorded a fake lien against HOA property or a director's home. How does the board get it removed?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

How an HOA board removes a fraudulent lien filed against common area or a director's home, using Texas 51.903, Florida 817.535 and Colorado spurious lien law.

Part of the HOA board handbook: running the board.

The short answer

Do not pay it, do not negotiate with the filer, and do not wait for it to go away. A lien that no statute, contract or court supports can still sit in the county records and cloud title to the common area or to a director's house until someone asks a judge to clear it. Texas, Florida and Colorado each give owners a court route built for exactly this. Texas Government Code section 51.903 lets the property owner file a short sworn motion that a district judge can rule on from the paperwork alone, with no filing fee. Colorado's spurious lien statute, C.R.S. 38-35-204, puts the filer in front of a judge 14 to 21 days after service and awards attorney fees to the winner. Florida Statutes section 817.535(8) gives anyone harmed by a false recorded instrument a civil action, and the filing itself can be a felony. The board's job is to move quickly, get the association's attorney involved, and keep a clean paper trail. Procedures vary by state and by your governing documents, and this guide is education, not legal advice.

What these filings look like in an HOA

They almost always follow a fight. An owner gets fined, sent to collections or served with a foreclosure notice, and a few weeks later a document lands in the county records claiming the association, or the directors who voted, owe the owner a large sum. Some are styled as a commercial lien or an affidavit of obligation. Some are financing statements filed with the secretary of state that name individual directors as debtors. Many cite no statute at all, or cite federal laws that have nothing to do with liens. You may hear about it three ways. The filer mails copies to make a point. A title search turns it up when the association refinances, sells a strip of common area or a director sells a home. Or the clerk tells you: in Texas, section 51.901(a) and (b) require a clerk who believes in good faith that a filing is fraudulent to mail the property owner a notice within two business days. In Colorado, C.R.S. 38-35-202(1) lets the clerk and recorder refuse a document it believes is a spurious lien, so some never get recorded at all.

The first week, in order

1. Get a certified copy of the recorded document from the county clerk and note the recording number and date. 2. Search the county's grantor and grantee index under the association's legal name and each director's name, and run a search of the secretary of state's financing statement records. Filers who do this once often do it several times. 3. Call the association's attorney the same day and send the copies. 4. Notify the directors and officers insurer in writing; ask whether defense costs for a director named personally are covered. 5. File a police report and send copies to the county or district attorney. 6. Tell every director not to reply to the filer, sign anything the filer sends, or post about it. One person, usually counsel, speaks for the board. 7. Hold a board meeting, in executive session where your state and bylaws allow it for legal matters, and pass a motion like this: "Moved that the board retain [attorney] to seek removal of the instrument recorded as [number] in [county] and any related filings, to notify the association's insurers, and to spend up to $[amount] on this matter without further approval."

The Texas route

Section 51.901(c)(2) presumes a lien document is fraudulent if no state or federal law provides for it, the owner never agreed to it, and no court imposed it. That describes nearly every retaliation lien. Under section 51.903(a), the owner files a verified motion with the district clerk using the form printed in the statute. The judge may decide from the attached document alone, ex parte and without testimony, under 51.903(c). The district clerk charges no filing fee (51.903(d)), and the county clerk charges nothing to record the judge's finding (51.903(f)). If the filer also used the secretary of state, section 51.905(b) lets you file a certified copy of the finding there for $15. Before or alongside the motion, have counsel send the filer a written request for a release by certified mail, return receipt requested. Under Penal Code section 32.49, a holder of a fraudulent lien who refuses to release it within 21 days of that notice is presumed to intend harm, and the offense is a Class A misdemeanor. For damages, Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 12.002(b) makes a person who knowingly files a fraudulent lien with intent to cause injury liable for the greater of $10,000 or actual damages, plus court costs, reasonable attorney's fees and exemplary damages. Section 12.003(a)(8) lets the property owner bring that suit, and the attorney general and local prosecutors can too.

The Florida and Colorado routes

In Florida, section 817.535(2)(a) makes it a third-degree felony to file an instrument containing a materially false statement that affects an owner's interest in property, with intent to defraud or harass. A second offense is a second-degree felony. The civil remedy in 817.535(8) does not depend on criminal charges. The association or director files suit and records a notice of lis pendens that describes the challenged instrument. If the court finds the instrument false, it can declare it void, order it sealed from the records, and bar the filer from recording anything without a judge's approval. On a finding of intent to defraud or harass, the court awards actual and punitive damages and may add a $2,500 civil penalty per instrument. The prevailing party recovers fees, so be sure of your facts. Construction liens are handled under section 713.31 instead. In Colorado, C.R.S. 38-35-201(4) defines a spurious lien in terms close to the Texas test. Section 38-35-203 says a spurious lien stops affecting the property after 35 days unless the filer sues to enforce it and records a lis pendens, but the document still sits in the public record, which is why a court order releasing it is worth getting. Section 38-35-204 lets the owner petition the district court with a supporting affidavit. The court can issue the order to show cause ex parte, set the hearing 14 to 21 days after service, and declare the lien invalid if the filer does not appear. The court must award costs and reasonable attorney fees to the prevailing party, and a certified copy of the order can be recorded.

When the target is a director's own home

If the lien names a director's house rather than the common area, the director is the property owner and normally signs the motion or petition. The association is not a bystander, though. The director is in this position because of a board vote. Read the bylaws and articles for indemnification language, and check the D&O policy before anyone spends money. Our guide on director liability insurance and indemnification covers how those provisions usually work. Many boards adopt a motion authorizing the association's attorney to represent the director, or to reimburse reasonable costs, so the director is not paying out of pocket to clear a lien filed over association business. Record that decision in the minutes. Then follow up: the director should confirm the court's finding is recorded in the same county records and should pull a fresh title report a month later to make sure nothing new has been filed.

A sample timeline

Day 0: the clerk's notice or a title search reveals the filing. Day 1: certified copy ordered, attorney engaged, insurer notified. Day 2: police report filed, directors told not to respond. Days 3 to 5: board approves the engagement and budget; counsel sends the release demand by certified mail. Week 2: the Texas motion, Florida complaint and lis pendens, or Colorado petition is filed. Weeks 3 to 6: in Colorado, the show cause hearing falls 14 to 21 days after the filer is served; in Texas, the judge may rule on the papers. After the ruling: record the order or finding with the county clerk, file it with the secretary of state if a financing statement was involved, give the title company a copy, and put a reminder on the calendar to search the records again in 90 days. Your county may move faster or slower, so treat these as targets, not deadlines.

Mistakes boards make

Paying a little to make it stop. That invites the next filing and can look like an admission. Letting individual directors argue with the filer by email or on social media, which hands the filer material and undercuts the claim that the document is baseless. Using the Texas fraudulent lien motion against a real but disputed lien, such as a contractor's mechanic's lien over an unpaid invoice. The statute's motion form states that it does not seek to invalidate a legitimate lien and warns of sanctions for frivolous motions; that dispute belongs in a different proceeding. Winning the order and never recording it, so the lien keeps showing up in title searches. Checking only the county records and missing a financing statement at the secretary of state. Saying nothing to owners while rumors spread; a two-sentence notice that the board is aware of an invalid filing and counsel is handling it is enough. If the filer is the same owner who has been sending threats to directors, read our guide on what to do when an owner harasses HOA board members, since a lien is often one piece of a larger pattern.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Leave the next board a clean record

Minutes, votes, documents and board decisions stay in one place when directors change. Free to start.