OurHOA
Pets & parking

An owner wants to widen their driveway or add a parking pad. How should our HOA board review the request?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

How an HOA board reviews a request to widen a driveway or add a parking pad: curb cuts, runoff, 811 calls, setbacks, TX, FL and CO law, and approval wording.

Part of the HOA board handbook: running the board.

The short answer

Treat a driveway widening as a change to the lot, not a paint job. More concrete means more runoff, a bigger curb cut and, often, a car parked where a lawn used to be. Most of these requests are reasonable and should be approved with conditions. The ones that cause trouble are the ones nobody measured. The committee decides location, size and appearance. The city decides the curb cut, the permit and any limit on paved lot coverage. The parking rules in the declaration decide what may park on the new slab once it exists. Keep those three questions apart and the review gets short. Rules vary by state and by each community's governing documents. This guide is education, not legal advice.

Ask what the slab is for

Put one question on the application: what will be parked here? The answer changes the review. A third car for a teenage driver is the common case. A side-yard pad for a boat or travel trailer is a different request, because most declarations restrict where recreational vehicles may be kept, and approving the pad can read as approving the boat. A pad for a work truck may run into commercial vehicle rules. Say in the approval that it covers the paving only and that every vehicle on it remains subject to the parking rules. If your rules are vague on RVs, fix the rules first; do not try to fix them one driveway at a time. Our guide on whether an HOA can restrict RV, boat and trailer parking covers what those rules usually say.

Where state law touches a driveway

Texas. Property Code 202.004(a) presumes the association's discretionary decisions reasonable unless an owner proves by a preponderance of the evidence that they were arbitrary, capricious or discriminatory. Keep a short log of past driveway approvals with widths and setbacks, because consistency is the evidence. Associations with more than 40 lots, outside any period of declarant control over review, follow the written denial and board hearing steps in 209.00505. Florida. Section 720.3035(1)(a) limits review of location, size, type and appearance to what the declaration or the guidelines it authorizes state or reasonably infer, applied evenly to every owner. Section 720.3035(1)(c) bars the committee from requiring a building permit before it will review. Section 720.3035(3) matters for corner lots: a parcel has one front for setback purposes unless the documents say otherwise, and where the documents set no setback, the county or city setback applies and the association may not enforce a different one. Colorado. C.R.S. 38-33.3-106.5(1)(d.5) bars an association from prohibiting use of a public right-of-way that follows the local government's rules, or from requiring that the right-of-way be used in a certain way. The apron and curb cut on a public street are the city's call. The committee still reviews the part of the driveway on the owner's lot.

Who owns the curb

Look at the plat before anything else. The answer splits these requests into two kinds. Public streets. The curb, the apron and usually the strip between sidewalk and street belong to the city or county. The owner needs the city's driveway or right-of-way permit, and the city sets the maximum curb cut width. The committee's approval should require that permit and stop at the property line. Private streets the association owns. Now the curb is common area, and cutting it is a decision for the board as property owner, not just for the architectural committee. Require a licensed contractor, a certificate of insurance naming the association, and a written agreement that the owner pays to restore any curb, gutter or sidewalk damaged by the work and maintains the new apron afterward. If the declaration requires a vote to alter common area, follow it. Ask the association's attorney if the documents are unclear.

Follow the water

Every square foot of new concrete sheds rain that used to soak in. Ask the owner to mark on the site plan which way the new slab slopes and where the water goes. This is not only a neighbor courtesy. Texas Water Code 11.086 says no person may divert or impound the natural flow of surface water in a way that damages another's property by overflow, and it gives the injured owner remedies at law and in equity. If a slab sends water into the neighbor's garage, an approval that never asked about drainage is a poor exhibit for the association. Set three rules: the slab drains to the street or the owner's own yard, never across a side lot line; nothing is poured in a drainage easement or across a swale without the drainage plan owner's written consent; and downspouts that now land on concrete get extended or redirected. Permeable pavers are worth allowing outright. The EPA's permeable pavement fact sheet lists driveways among the uses where pervious concrete, porous asphalt and permeable pavers can replace conventional paving, and it flags sloped sites: past 2 percent, the base may need terracing so water does not run through the pavement layers. They also need occasional cleaning, since sediment clogs them.

Width, placement and look

Write numbers into the guidelines so the tenth request gets the same answer as the first. Standards worth putting on paper: - A cap on paving in the front yard, such as no more than 40 or 50 percent of the area between the house and the street. - Side pads set behind the front wall of the house, with a minimum distance from the side lot line, such as 3 feet, and a planting strip or fence on the side facing the neighbor. - Materials that match or complement the existing driveway; broom-finish concrete beside a stamped one looks like a patch. - No gravel or loose rock pads in front yards, where they wash into the street. - Screening for any pad meant to hold a trailer or boat, if the rules allow one at all. If the documents already name options, such as two approved paver colors, Florida owners may choose among them under 720.3035(2), and the committee should not narrow the list.

Before anyone digs

Make the utility locate a condition, because a cut gas or fiber line is the expensive way to find out where it ran. In Texas, Utilities Code 251.151 requires notice to a notification center no earlier than 14 days and no later than 48 hours before excavation begins, not counting weekends and legal holidays. The chapter defines excavation as using powered or mechanized equipment to disturb soil 16 or more inches deep. In Florida, 556.105 requires notice at least 2 full business days before excavation, and the locate information is valid for 30 calendar days. In Colorado, C.R.S. 9-1.5-103(3)(b) requires notice at least two business days before excavation, not counting the day of notice. The locate covers lines the utilities own. The association's own sprinkler mains and landscape lighting wire may not appear, so have the landscape contractor flag any association lines near the work.

Application, timeline and approval wording

Ask for a survey or site plan showing the existing and new paving with dimensions, distance to each side lot line and any easement, the slope and drainage direction, the material and color, the curb cut width, the contractor, and the intended use. Timeline: log the date the application is complete. Within a week, send the owner a single written list of anything missing. In the second or third week, one committee member visits with the plan and takes dated photos of the curb, gutter and sidewalk. Decide in writing by day 30, or sooner if the documents set a shorter deadline. For a denial in Texas under 209.00505, send the notice by certified mail, hand delivery or electronic delivery, explain the basis in reasonable detail with any changes that would allow approval, and tell the owner they may request a board hearing within 30 days. The board holds that hearing within 30 days of the request, with at least 10 days' notice. In Florida, 720.3035(4)(a) requires a written denial naming the rule or covenant relied on and the part of the plan that does not conform. Approval wording: 'The Architectural Committee approves the driveway [widening / parking pad] at [address] shown in your application dated [date], on these conditions: (1) dimensions and location as shown, at least [3] feet from the side lot line; (2) [material and color] to match the existing driveway; (3) the paving drains to the street or your own lot as shown and not onto any neighboring lot or easement; (4) you obtain any city driveway or right-of-way permit and request a utility locate before digging; (5) you pay to repair any curb, gutter, sidewalk or association irrigation damaged by the work; and (6) this approval covers the paving only, and every vehicle parked on it remains subject to the association's parking rules.'

Mistakes boards make

Approving a pad and, by silence, the trailer. Condition six in the wording above prevents most of the follow-up fights. Ignoring the corner lot. Measure setbacks from the front the documents name, and in Florida remember the one-front rule. Skipping the photo of the curb. Without a dated picture taken before work starts, nobody can prove whose truck cracked the gutter. Calling a teardown a repair. Replacing a cracked driveway in the same footprint and finish is maintenance. Pouring it a foot wider is a new application. When the concrete is poured before anyone applies, use our guide on handling an owner who built without HOA architectural approval. To put these standards into the community's written rules, see our guide on how to write HOA architectural guidelines.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Leave the next board a clean record

Minutes, votes, documents and board decisions stay in one place when directors change. Free to start.