An owner sued our HOA in small claims or justice court. What does the board do now?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised October 18, 2026

What an HOA board does when an owner files in small claims or justice court: answer deadlines, who appears, insurance notice, settlement votes, TX, FL and CO rules.

Part of the HOA board handbook: running the board.

The short answer

Treat the papers as a deadline, not an insult. Within a day or two of service, the president should log the date the association was served, send the petition to the insurance carrier and the association's attorney, and put the case on the agenda for a closed board session. Then the board decides three things by vote: who will appear for the association, whether to answer and defend or try to settle, and how much settlement authority that person has. Missing the answer date or the first hearing is the one mistake that turns a weak claim into a judgment, because both Texas and Florida rules let the plaintiff win by default. This guide covers the board's side of the case. Owners asking whether the association can sue them should read our guide on whether an HOA can take you to small claims court. Court rules vary by state and change, so this is general education, not legal advice.

Find the deadline on the first day

Each state runs its small claims court differently, and the clock starts at different points. In Texas, an owner suing for $20,000 or less, exclusive of interest, files in justice court under Government Code section 27.031. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 502.5 makes the answer due by the end of the 14th day after the day the association was served, moved to the next business day if that day falls on a weekend or holiday. A general denial is a valid answer. If no answer arrives and service was proper, Rule 503.1 says the judge must render a default judgment. In Florida, small claims covers cases up to $8,000 under Small Claims Rule 7.010(b). The first event is a pretrial conference the clerk sets no more than 50 days after filing, and Rule 7.090(c) says filing a written defense does not excuse showing up. Under Rule 7.170(a), a defendant who does not appear is in default. In Colorado, county court small claims handles up to $7,500 under C.R.S. 13-6-403, and that section expressly covers disputes over association assessments, fines and fees. Read the summons or notice for the exact trial or response date, and call the clerk if anything is unclear.

Notify the insurer before anyone says anything

Pull the association's directors and officers policy and the general liability policy and read the notice section. Most of these policies cover claims made against the association and its directors, and most require prompt written notice of a claim or suit. Late notice is one of the easiest ways to lose coverage you paid for. Send the carrier or broker a copy of the petition, the date of service, and a short factual summary the same week. Ask in writing whether the carrier will defend or appoint counsel, and whether it must approve any settlement. Many policies bar the insured from agreeing to pay a claim without the insurer's consent. Until the carrier answers, no director should discuss the dispute with the owner or post about it in the neighborhood group. Our guide on HOA director liability insurance and indemnification explains how these policies respond.

Decide who stands up for the association

The association is a corporation or unincorporated association, so a person has to appear for it, and each state limits who that can be. Texas Rule 500.3 lets an entity appear through an employee, owner, officer or partner who is not an attorney, or through an attorney. Florida Rule 7.050(a)(2) allows any principal with legal authority to bind the entity, defined to include an officer, or any employee authorized in writing by a principal. Florida also bars a non-attorney from representing a business entity on appeal. Colorado limits lawyers in small claims: C.R.S. 13-6-407 says a nonprofit corporation appears through a duly elected nonattorney officer or an employee, and if one side brings an attorney, the other side may too. Pick the director who knows the facts, keeps their temper and can attend every date. Do not send the director who has been feuding with the owner.

A motion the board can adopt

Make the decisions in a closed or executive session where your state and documents allow it for pending litigation, then record the vote without the strategy. Sample wording: "Moved that the board authorizes [name], Secretary, to appear for the association in [owner name] v. [association name], case number [number], in [court]; directs the President to notify the association's insurance carriers in writing by [date]; authorizes the representative to settle the case for an amount not exceeding $[amount], subject to any required insurer consent; and directs that all communication with the plaintiff about the case go through the representative or counsel." The dollar cap matters. Mediation is common in all three states, and Florida Rule 7.090(f) requires a nonlawyer at mediation to bring the party's signed written authority and full settlement authority. A representative with no number in hand often ends up returning for another hearing.

Build the file the judge will read

Small claims judges decide on documents and short testimony, so assemble a binder with three copies: one for the judge, one for the owner, one for your representative. Include the governing document sections that apply, the owner's ledger or the violation history, every letter sent with proof of mailing, the minutes where the board acted, photos with dates, and any vendor invoice or estimate the claim turns on. Put a one-page timeline on top. If the owner's claim is that a fine skipped required notice or a hearing, check that notice before trial, because judges look hard at procedure. If the association has its own claim against the owner, such as unpaid assessments, decide early whether to file a counterclaim. Texas Rule 502.6 allows one within the court's limit. Florida Rule 7.100(a) treats a counterclaim from the same transaction as abandoned unless filed at least 5 days before the pretrial conference. Colorado's C.R.S. 13-6-408 sends counterclaims over the limit to a higher court.

A sample timeline for a Texas justice court case

Day 0: the constable serves the president. Day 1: the president emails the board, the carrier and the attorney, and scans the petition. Day 3: the carrier acknowledges the claim. Day 5: the board meets in executive session and adopts the motion above. Day 10: the representative files a written answer with the clerk and sends a copy to the owner, leaving four days of margin before the Rule 502.5 deadline. Day 30 to 60: the court sets trial or mediation, and the representative prepares the binder. Trial day: the representative presents the timeline and documents in ten minutes or less. After judgment, either side may appeal within 21 days after the judgment is signed under Rule 506.1, and Rule 506.3 says the county court tries the case over from the start. A defendant's appeal bond is twice the judgment amount, so the board should know before trial what it would do if it loses.

Mistakes that cost boards the case

Ignoring the papers because the claim looks silly is the big one. A default judgment is a real judgment, and undoing it takes more work than answering would have. Other common errors: letting the board member at the center of the dispute argue the case, settling without the carrier's written consent, discussing the case in an open forum or email thread the owner can quote, and paying a claim from reserves without a board vote. Watch the fee rules, too. Colorado's C.R.S. 38-33.3-123(1)(c) says the court shall award reasonable attorney fees and costs to the prevailing party in a civil action to enforce or defend the act or the governing documents, so a case that moves out of small claims can get expensive for the losing side. If the facts are contested or the dollar amount is near the limit, call the attorney before the answer date. Our guide on how to hire an HOA attorney covers what to ask for and what it costs.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More on board & governance

Or browse all hoa boards & governance guides.