OurHOA
Board & governance

Our whole HOA board is elected at once. How do we switch to staggered terms?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

How an HOA board moves from electing every seat at once to staggered terms: the bylaw amendment, a transition election, sample wording, and TX, FL and CO rules.

Part of the HOA board handbook: running the board.

The short answer

Amend the bylaws so seats are split into groups with terms that end in different years, and add a one-time transition clause that tells you which winners get the longer term at the first election under the new rule. On a five-seat board the usual pattern is two-year terms, with three seats up in odd years and two in even years. At the transition election all five seats are filled, the top three vote-getters serve two years and the next two serve one year. From the following year on, only part of the board is ever on the ballot. State nonprofit law allows this in all three of our core states. Texas Business Organizations Code 22.209 says directors may be divided into classes whose terms do not have to be uniform. Florida Statutes 617.0806 lets the articles or bylaws divide directors into classes. Colorado C.R.S. 7-128-106 lets the bylaws stagger terms by dividing directors into any number of groups. What none of them do is stagger your board for you. The bylaws have to say it, and the amendment has to pass by whatever vote your documents require. These statutes govern incorporated associations. An unincorporated association relies on its own documents. Rules vary by state and by your own governing documents, so treat this as general education, not legal advice.

Why boards make the change

A board elected all at once can be replaced all at once. In a 60-home community that usually happens the year a contested issue, such as a dues increase or a special assessment, brings out a slate of newcomers. The new board then starts without anyone who knows where the bank tokens are, which vendor contracts auto-renew, or why the pool resurfacing was pushed a year. Staggering keeps at least two experienced directors on the board through any single election. It also shrinks the recruiting problem. Finding two candidates a year is easier than finding five every other year, and a volunteer who sees only two open seats is less likely to assume someone else will step up. The change does not limit owners. Every seat still goes to the voters on a regular cycle, and owners who want a different board can still elect one over two annual meetings. Say that plainly when you present the amendment, because the first objection you will hear is that the board is trying to protect itself.

Decide the design before anyone drafts

Settle four numbers at a board meeting and put them in the minutes. Board size. Three, five or seven seats. An odd number avoids tie votes. Term length. Two years suits most associations of 26 to 150 homes. Three-year terms give more continuity but are a harder ask for volunteers. The split. With two-year terms, a three-seat board elects two seats one year and one the next; five seats split three and two; seven seats split four and three. With three-year terms, five seats split two, two and one. The transition method. Choose one and write it down. Rank by votes: the candidates with the most votes get the longer terms. Designated seats: the ballot lists Seat A (two years) and Seat B (one year) and candidates run for a specific seat. Drawing lots among the winners after the election. Ranking by votes is the most common and the easiest to explain.

Wording the board can adapt

Hand this to your attorney as a draft. Bylaw text: "Section 3.2. Number and terms. The board of directors consists of five directors. Directors serve staggered two-year terms. Three directors are elected at each annual meeting held in an odd-numbered year and two directors are elected at each annual meeting held in an even-numbered year. Each director serves until a successor is elected and qualified." Transition clause: "Section 3.2.1. Transition. At the first annual meeting held after this amendment is adopted, all five seats will be filled. The three candidates receiving the most votes will serve two-year terms and the two candidates receiving the next most votes will serve one-year terms. If a tie affects which candidate receives a two-year term, the tie will be broken by drawing lots at the meeting. If fewer than five candidates are elected, the candidates elected will receive the two-year terms first, and any seat left open will carry a one-year term. This section expires once the transition is complete." How that open seat gets filled depends on your state. In Texas, Property Code 209.00593(a) says a seat whose term has expired must be filled by an owner election, while appointment is for vacancies, so ask the attorney which applies before you rely on an appointment. Motion for the minutes: "Motion to propose to the members the attached amendment to Article III of the bylaws, providing for staggered two-year director terms, and to submit it for a vote at the [date] meeting of the members." Notice paragraph for owners: "Right now all five board seats are elected every two years, so the whole board can turn over in one night. The proposed amendment keeps two-year terms but puts three seats on the ballot in odd years and two in even years. At the first election after it passes, the top three vote-getters serve two years and the next two serve one year. Every seat still goes to an owner vote on a regular schedule."

Getting the amendment adopted

Read the amendment article of your bylaws first. It tells you who can amend them, what vote it takes and how notice works. Then check the default rules in your state, which apply only where the documents are silent. Texas. A Texas association's bylaws are a dedicatory instrument under Property Code 202.001(1), and under 202.006 a dedicatory instrument has no effect until it is filed in the real property records of each county where the community sits. Send the signed amendment to the county clerk promptly. An amendment adopted in March but never filed does not govern the next election. Florida. Unless the governing documents or the law say otherwise, Florida Statutes 720.306(1)(b) lets an association amend any governing document by a vote of two-thirds of the voting interests, and requires copies of a recorded amendment to go to members within 30 days after recording. Colorado. C.R.S. 7-130-201 lets the board amend the bylaws unless the nonprofit act, the articles or the bylaws reserve that power to the members, and the members may amend them as well. Many HOA bylaws do reserve director terms to an owner vote. If yours do, or if you are unsure, put it to the owners. A change to who sits on the board is the kind of decision owners expect to make. Wherever you are, hold the amendment vote before the election it is meant to govern, ideally at a separate meeting or by ballot that closes weeks ahead. Running both at the same meeting invites a fight about which rule applied to which ballot. Our guide on how to run an HOA board election covers the transition election itself, and our guide on how to fill an HOA board vacancy covers appointments between elections, which is where rotations most often break.

A sample timeline

This assumes an annual meeting in March and a five-seat board whose terms all end at that meeting. September: the board agrees on size, term length, split and transition method, and records the decision. October: the association attorney reviews the draft against the declaration, articles and state law. November: send owners the proposed text and the plain-language notice. Hold a short town hall or take questions by email. December to January: owners vote on the amendment by the method your documents allow. January: in Texas, file the adopted amendment with the county clerk. In Florida, record it if your documents require recording and send copies within 30 days after recording. Late January: the call for candidates goes out under the new rule, and the notice says that the top three vote-getters will serve two years. March: transition election. The inspector or tellers record the vote counts, and the minutes list each winner with the date that director's term ends. Next March: two seats on the ballot. The board is staggered from here on.

Mistakes that undo the work

Shortening a sitting director's term. Florida 617.0805(2) and Colorado 7-128-105(3) both say a decrease in the term of office does not shorten an incumbent director's term. Phase the change in at the next regular election instead of cutting anyone off midterm. Leaving out the transition clause. A bylaw that simply says terms are staggered, with no rule for who gets the shorter term, leaves the board to decide after the votes are counted. That looks self-serving even when it is not. Forgetting the vacancy rule. Texas Property Code 209.00593(a) and Florida 720.306(9)(c) say an appointee fills out the unexpired term, unless Florida bylaws provide otherwise. Florida 617.0805(3) and Colorado 7-128-105(4) set the same default for nonprofits. Fill a vacancy for the full new term and the rotation drifts back toward everyone ending at once. No record of who ends when. Keep a one-page roster with each seat, the director holding it, and the annual meeting at which it ends. Update it after every election and every appointment. Overlooking the holdover rule. In all three states a director whose term ends keeps serving until a successor takes office (Texas BOC 22.208(b) where the bylaws are silent, Florida 617.0806 and 617.0805(4), Colorado 7-128-105(5)). If no one runs for a seat, the seat does not go dark, but it does not move to a new cycle either. Fill it at the next election for whatever term remains in its group.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Leave the next board a clean record

Minutes, votes, documents and board decisions stay in one place when directors change. Free to start.