OurHOA
Home & property

How do we sell a strip of HOA common area to the owner next door?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

Board steps when a neighbor asks to buy a strip of HOA common area: title check, survey, price, owner vote, deed, recording and the tax on the sale.

Part of the HOA board handbook: running the board.

The short answer

The board cannot sell common area on its own say-so in most communities. Before anyone talks price, pull the declaration and the deed that put the land in the association's name, and find the vote the documents or your state's statute require. If the sale is allowed, the sequence is: survey the strip, set a price at fair value, put a signed contract to the owners for approval, then sign and record a deed. The buyer pays the costs. Expect three to six months from the first email to the recorded deed. The request usually comes from an owner whose fence already sits on the strip, or who wants room for a pool, a side yard or a wider driveway. Treat it as a sale of association property that every owner has a stake in, not as a favor to a neighbor. Rules vary by state and by your governing documents, and this guide is education, not legal advice. Have the association's attorney draft the contract and the deed.

First, confirm the association can sell this land

Four checks, in this order. 1. Who holds title. Get the vesting deed from the county records. Some developers never deeded the common area over, and in some subdivisions the land shown as open space belongs to a separate entity or the city. Florida's definition in section 720.301(2) counts land dedicated to members' use by a recorded plat as common area whether or not title was ever conveyed to the association, so a plat note can control even where the deed is missing. 2. What the plat says. A strip labeled drainage easement, landscape buffer or open space may come with conditions the city will enforce. Call the planning office and ask whether selling it needs a replat or a lot line adjustment, and whether the buyer's lot can absorb it under zoning. 3. Easements and pipes. A utility line, storm drain or irrigation main under the strip stays put after the sale. Reserve an easement in the deed for anything the association still needs to reach. 4. Liens and loans. If the association borrowed against the common area, the lender has to release the strip.

The owner vote in Texas, Florida and Colorado

Colorado sets the rule by statute. C.R.S. 38-33.3-312(1) lets the association convey portions of the common elements only if owners holding at least 67 percent of the votes agree, including 67 percent of the votes held by owners other than the declarant, or a larger percentage if the declaration requires one. Owners of every unit a limited common element is assigned to must also agree before that piece can be sold. Section 312(5) voids a conveyance that skips these steps, and 312(6) bars any sale that takes away a unit's access or support. Section 38-33.3-117 does not list 312 among the sections that reach communities created before July 1, 1992, so an older Colorado community looks to its declaration. Texas subdivisions governed by Property Code chapter 209 have no statutory conveyance vote, so the declaration and bylaws set it. Read the article on common area and the amendment article together. If the documents say nothing about selling, ask the attorney before treating it as a board decision. Texas condominiums are different: Property Code 82.102(a)(9) lets the association convey real property in its own name except common elements, which the unit owners own together. Florida chapter 720 does not set a vote for selling common area either, so the declaration controls there as well.

Survey, price and who pays

Hire a licensed land surveyor to stake the strip and write a legal description that ties into the plat. The deed will use that description word for word, so do not let the buyer's fence contractor or a county GIS map stand in for it. Our guide on hiring a land surveyor to mark common area boundaries covers what to order. Price the land at fair value. A director who sells a 20-foot strip to a neighbor for a dollar is giving away property the other owners paid to maintain, and that invites a claim against the board. A broker's opinion of value or a short appraisal is enough for a small strip. Divide by square footage and compare it with what nearby lots sold for. The buyer pays the survey, appraisal, attorney fees for the contract and deed, recording fees, any city replat fee and title insurance if they want it. Put that in the contract, and collect a deposit to cover the association's costs before you order the survey, refundable only if the owners vote the sale down.

Wording for the contract, the motion and the ballot

Colorado's 38-33.3-312(3) requires the agreement to be signed by the association in the same manner as a deed and to name a date after which it is void unless the owners approve it, and 312(4) says the contract cannot be enforced until they do. That is a sound structure in any state: sign a contract that is expressly subject to the owner vote, with an end date. Sample board motion: "I move that the board approve the attached agreement to sell the 1,850-square-foot portion of Common Area Lot 14 described in Exhibit A to the owner of 412 Elm Court for $9,250, subject to approval by the owners as the declaration requires, the buyer paying all closing costs, and the association reserving a drainage and utility easement over the full strip." Sample ballot question: "Do you approve the sale of the 1,850-square-foot portion of Common Area Lot 14 shown on the attached survey to the owner of 412 Elm Court for $9,250, with the sale proceeds deposited to the reserve fund? Yes / No." Attach the survey drawing and a photo. Owners vote no on what they cannot picture.

Closing the sale and recording the deed

Once the vote passes, record the result in the minutes with the tally and keep the ballots. The officers the bylaws authorize sign the deed. Recording rules are strict. Texas Property Code 12.001(b) bars recording a conveyance unless it is acknowledged before a notary or signed in front of two credible subscribing witnesses. Florida section 689.01 requires two subscribing witnesses on a deed. Under Colorado's 38-33.3-312(3), the association's deed must be recorded in every county where part of the community sits and takes effect only when recorded. Use a title company or the attorney to close it, so the deed, any lender release, the reserved easement and the city's lot combination are filed together. Then update the association's insurance schedule, the landscaping contract map and the assessment records if the declaration ties anything to lot size. Colorado's 312(1) says sale proceeds are an asset of the association. In every state, deposit them by board vote into the fund the ballot named.

The tax on the sale

Proceeds from selling land are not member dues. An association filing Form 1120-H reports the gain on Schedule D and line 5 of the return, and the IRS instructions say the flat 30 percent rate for residential associations applies to capital gains as well as ordinary income. The gain is the price minus the association's basis in the strip. When a developer deeded the common area to the association for nothing, that basis may be close to zero, which means most of the price can be taxable. Ask the CPA to work out the number before the board sets the price, and have the contract make the buyer pay all closing costs so the association's net matches what the owners approved.

A sample timeline

Week 1: the owner's written request arrives. The board acknowledges it and asks for a deposit toward costs. Weeks 2 to 4: title search, plat review, call to the city planning office and the survey. Weeks 5 to 6: value opinion, attorney drafts the contract, board approves it at an open meeting. Weeks 7 to 12: notice and ballot to owners under the declaration's voting rules, with the survey attached. Weeks 13 to 18: city replat or lot combination if needed, deed signed and recorded, proceeds deposited.

Mistakes boards make

Letting a director promise the neighbor a yes before the documents are read. Selling at a token price because the buyer has been mowing the strip. Skipping the reserved easement and then needing permission to reach your own storm drain. Treating a board vote as enough when the declaration calls for an owner vote, which leaves a deed any owner can challenge. Forgetting the tax and finding out at filing time. And selling one strip without a policy, then facing five more requests from the same row of houses. If the strip is only a few feet of fence encroachment, a written license may solve the problem without a sale; our guide on handling an owner encroaching on common area covers that route.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Leave the next board a clean record

Minutes, votes, documents and board decisions stay in one place when directors change. Free to start.