OurHOA
Board & governance

What should our HOA board do when the treasurer refuses to carry out a board vote?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

What an HOA board does when the treasurer won't pay approved bills, move reserves or hand over the books: written direction, backup signers, records, removal.

Part of the HOA board handbook: running the board.

The short answer

Put the board's decision in writing, give the treasurer a specific task and a date, and ask for a written reason if they still won't act. While you wait, make sure another authorized signer can pay the bills that can't wait. If the refusal holds past the deadline, the board can reassign the task, change the bank signers by resolution, or remove the treasurer from the office. In Texas, Florida and Colorado an officer's duties come from the bylaws and the board, so a treasurer who was outvoted still has to carry out the result or step aside. Before any of that, hear the objection. Sometimes the treasurer is the one person who read the reserve rules, and the vote was the mistake. Rules vary by state and by your declaration and bylaws, so use this as a guide to process, not legal advice for your community.

Sort out which kind of refusal you have

Refusals come in four kinds, and each calls for a different response. The treasurer thinks the vote is illegal or breaks the documents. Examples: paying an operating bill out of reserves when the declaration restricts reserve use, or paying a contract that skipped a bid rule. Take this one seriously. Ask for the objection in writing, read the provision they cite, and get a short opinion from the association's attorney or CPA if the board still disagrees. The treasurer lost the vote and is dragging their feet. This is the common one, and it usually ends once the direction is in writing with a date on it. The treasurer is overloaded, sick or out of town and won't admit it. Our guide on what to do when the treasurer is out for months covers splitting the work and naming a backup. The treasurer won't let anyone see the books. Treat that as a records problem first. If money is missing, stop reading this guide and follow our guide on what to do when an HOA treasurer takes association money.

What the law says about officers

In all three states the board runs the association and an officer carries out the job the bylaws and the board assign. Texas Business Organizations Code 22.201 puts the affairs of a nonprofit corporation in the hands of its board, and 3.103(b) says an officer performs the duties and has the authority provided by the governing documents or by the body that elected the officer. Florida 617.0841 says each officer performs the duties in the bylaws and, to the extent consistent with them, the duties the board prescribes. Colorado 7-128-302 uses almost the same words. Officers also carry a duty of care. Texas 22.235 protects an officer from liability unless the officer failed to act in good faith, with ordinary care and in a manner they reasonably believed was in the corporation's best interest. Florida 720.303(1) says HOA officers and directors have a fiduciary relationship to the members. Colorado 38-33.3-303(2)(b) shields non-declarant officers and board members except for wanton and willful acts or omissions, but 38-33.3-303(2.5) holds them to the 7-128-401 standards when investing reserve funds. That matters when the fight is over moving reserves out of checking and into the CDs or Treasury bills the board approved. A treasurer who simply ignores a reserve investment vote is taking a risk with their own conduct, not only the board's.

Give the direction in writing

Most of these standoffs live in hallway talk and text threads. Move it into the record. At a noticed board meeting, pass a motion that names the task, the amount, the account and the deadline. Sample motion: 'I move that the board direct the treasurer to transfer $60,000 from the operating account to the reserve money market account at First Community Bank by May 15, and to report completion to the board in writing. If the transfer is not complete by that date, the president and secretary, as authorized signers, are directed to make it.' The second sentence is the important one. It turns a personal standoff into a deadline with a fallback, and no one has to ask permission later. Then send the treasurer a short follow-up email from the secretary the next day: 'At the April 20 meeting the board voted 4 to 1 to transfer $60,000 to the reserve money market account by May 15. A copy of the draft minutes is attached. If you believe the transfer would violate our governing documents or the law, please send the specific provision by May 1 so the board can review it before the deadline.' Keep the tone flat. You may need to show this email to owners, the bank or a lawyer later.

Keep the bills paid while you sort it out

The insurance premium, payroll tax deposit and landscaper do not care about board politics. List every payment due in the next 45 days and who can make it today. Look at three things. Bank signers. Check who the bank has on file, not who the minutes say should be there. If the treasurer is the only signer or the only online banking administrator, fix that now. Most banks ask for a board resolution naming the new signers and removing old ones, usually on their own form, plus a copy of the minutes or a certificate signed by the secretary. Bring both to the branch together. Dual control. If a board resolution requires two signatures above a set amount and the account has only two signers, one holdout can stop every large payment. Name at least three signers so any two can act. Autopay and logins. Find out which bills come out automatically and from which account, and who holds the passwords for the payment portal, the accounting file and the tax accounts. Those logins belong to the association. Ask the treasurer to share them with a second officer, in writing, by a set date.

Get the records back

Bank statements, ledgers, invoices, tax filings and the accounting file are association records, not the treasurer's papers. The board needs them to run the association, and owners have a legal right to see many of them. Texas Property Code 209.005(c) requires a property owners' association to make its books and records, including financial records, reasonably available to owners. Florida 720.303(4) requires the association to keep its official records, including financial and accounting records, for at least 7 years. Florida also makes it a first-degree misdemeanor under 720.303(5)(e) to destroy accounting records, or to knowingly fail to create or maintain them, with intent to harm the association or its members. If the treasurer is holding records, send a written request that lists what you need and gives a date. Sample: 'The board requests that you deliver the following association records to the secretary by June 1: bank statements for the last 12 months, the QuickBooks file and login, the 2025 tax return and supporting workpapers, and all vendor invoices for 2026. These are association records under our bylaws and state law. Please let us know if any item is not in your possession.' Download fresh statements from the bank yourself at the same time, so the board is not waiting on one person to see its own balance.

Removing the treasurer from office

If the deadline passes and the treasurer still won't act or step down, the board can take the title back. Texas BOC 3.104(a) lets the governing authority remove an officer for or without cause unless the governing documents say otherwise. Florida 617.0842(2) lets the board remove any officer at any time, with or without cause. Colorado 7-128-303(4) says the same unless the bylaws provide otherwise. Read your bylaws first for notice or vote requirements. Removing someone as treasurer does not remove them from the board. They keep their seat, their vote and their right to see association records as a director until the owners act under the bylaws and state law. Our guide on handling an HOA president who acts without board approval covers the same split between office and seat from the other direction. Sample motion: 'I move that [name] be removed from the office of treasurer effective immediately, that [name] be appointed treasurer for the rest of the term, and that the secretary deliver the bank's signer change form to First Community Bank within three business days.' Keep the discussion about the task that wasn't done, not the person.

Mistakes that make it worse

Changing the bank signers or passwords without a board vote. Even if the treasurer is wrong, a lockout done by two officers on their own hands the treasurer a better grievance than the one they started with. Accusing the treasurer of theft before anyone has looked at a bank statement. Pull the statements first. Many refusals turn out to be stubbornness or honest disagreement, and a false accusation in an owner email can become a defamation claim. Ignoring a legal objection because it came from the person who lost the vote. Read the provision. If they're right, revote. Letting a hard deadline slip while the board argues. A lapsed insurance policy or late payroll tax deposit costs more than the dispute is worth. Never writing down who does what. After this is settled, adopt a one-page list of treasurer duties, name a backup signer, and add a standing agenda item where the treasurer confirms each directed task is done.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Leave the next board a clean record

Minutes, votes, documents and board decisions stay in one place when directors change. Free to start.