OurHOA
Rentals & neighbors

How do we run a rental cap and waiting list in our HOA?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

How an HOA board runs a rental cap: counting leased homes, a fair waiting list, grandfathered owners, hardship requests, and TX, FL and CO rules.

Part of the HOA board handbook: residents and communication.

The short answer

A rental cap holds up only if the board can show, on any day, how many homes are leased, which owner is next in line, and why. That takes three things: one roster that marks every home as owner-occupied or leased, one waiting list stamped with the date each complete request arrived, and a written rule for when a leasing slot opens and closes. Apply all three the same way to every owner, directors included. Most cap fights start when an owner learns that someone who asked later got a slot first. Rules vary by state and by your governing documents, and this guide is education, not legal advice. Have the association's attorney read the leasing article and your written procedure before you rely on them.

Confirm the cap exists and who it binds

Read the leasing article of the declaration word for word. Write down the cap as a number or a percentage, what counts as leased (does a relative living rent-free count?), whether a permit ends when a lease ends, any minimum ownership period before an owner can lease, and any hardship clause. If the cap appears only in a board rule, ask the attorney whether the board had the power to adopt it. A cap usually belongs in the declaration. Texas. For subdivisions under Property Code chapter 209 (condominiums are excluded by 209.003(d)), section 209.016(d) leaves room for leasing and occupancy restrictions. Section 209.016(b) bars any provision that makes a tenant apply to the association for approval, or that requires a credit report or the tenant's rental application. So the list decides whether a home may be leased, never who the tenant is. Under 202.006, a dedicatory instrument has no effect until it is filed in the county real property records, so file the cap amendment and any leasing rule. Florida. Under 720.306(1)(h)1, a governing document or amendment enacted after July 1, 2021 that prohibits or regulates rentals binds only owners who take title after it takes effect or who consent to it. Under (h)2, an amendment that regulates leases shorter than 6 months, or bars renting a home more than three times in a calendar year, applies to everyone. Condominiums have a similar rule in 718.110(13). Colorado. The Common Interest Ownership Act has no section on rental caps, so a cap comes through the declaration. Section 38-33.3-217(1)(a)(I) lets owners holding more than 50 percent of the votes amend it, or a larger share the declaration sets, up to 67 percent. A higher requirement in the declaration is treated as 67 percent. California, for comparison. Civil Code 4741(b) bars any cap below 25 percent of the separate interests. It also lets an association ban rentals of 30 days or less under 4741(c).

Build the count before you touch the list

Add four columns to the owner roster: status (owner-occupied, leased under a permit, grandfathered, or exempt), the date the permit began, the current lease end date, and the source of each entry. Fill it from lease registration forms, not from guesses. Our guide on setting up a lease registration program covers the form and what you may ask for. Then do the arithmetic once and write it down. A 20 percent cap in an 84-home community works out to 16.8 homes. Some declarations say how to round, and many say nothing. If yours is silent, get the attorney's answer, put it in the written procedure, and stop deciding it case by case. Settle the same way whether grandfathered homes count toward the cap. One named director keeps the roster, and a second checks it against the forms each quarter.

Run the waiting list the same way every time

An owner joins the list with a written request that names the home and the owner of record. The request's place in line is the date and time a complete request arrived. Acknowledge each one in writing with a position number. Publish the list by position and lot or unit number, without owner names, in the members' area or with the minutes, and update it each time it moves. A list that only the president can see is the one owners will challenge. When a slot opens, offer it to the top owner in writing and set two deadlines: one to accept, and one to sign a lease once accepted. Thirty days for each is a reasonable start; give more in a slow rental market. If the owner declines or misses a deadline, follow your written rule, whether that means dropping to the bottom or coming off the list, and offer the slot to the next owner the same day. Unless the declaration says otherwise, write the procedure so a place in line belongs to the owner and ends when that owner sells. Offer wording to adapt: 'A leasing slot has opened under Article __ of the declaration. You are first on the waiting list for Lot __. To accept, reply in writing by [date]. Once you accept, you have until [date] to sign a lease and return the lease registration form. If you do not reply by [date], the slot goes to the next owner on the list and your request will be handled under section __ of the leasing procedure.'

When permits end and grandfathered homes change hands

Most caps tie the permit to a lease, not to the home forever. Read whether a permit survives a gap between tenants, and for how long. A common pattern is that the permit lapses if the home sits unleased, or the owner moves back in, for a set number of days. Check lease end dates each month and ask the owner in writing what happened when one passes. A lapsed permit goes to the top of the list, and it should not wait until someone notices. In Florida, track grandfathered owners with their deed date from the county records next to the amendment's recording date. Under 720.306(1)(h)4, a transfer to an affiliated entity, a transfer that leaves beneficial ownership unchanged, or an heir becoming the owner is not a change of ownership, so those owners keep their status. A sale to an outside buyer ends it, because the buyer takes title after the amendment. Put the leasing status of each home in the resale disclosure or estoppel package where your state's forms allow it.

Hardship and accommodation requests

Many declarations let the board grant a temporary lease outside the cap for hardship: military orders, a job transfer, a death in the family, or a home that will not sell. Grant one only if your documents allow it, and decide every request against a written standard so the outcome does not depend on who asks. Set a fixed term, such as 12 months, require a new request to extend it, and record the vote and the reason in the minutes without medical or financial detail. A request tied to a disability is different. Under the Fair Housing Act, 42 U.S.C. 3604(f)(3)(B), refusing a reasonable accommodation in rules or policies can be discrimination when the accommodation may be needed for equal use and enjoyment of a dwelling. Treat it as an accommodation request, not a hardship request, and follow our guide on handling a reasonable accommodation request. Do not ask for a diagnosis. Sample hardship motion: 'Moved, that the board grant the owner of Lot __ a temporary leasing permit under Article __ for a term of 12 months beginning [date], based on the written hardship request received [date], and that this permit does not change the order of the waiting list.'

A sample year for an 84-home community

January: the secretary updates the roster from registration forms. The count shows 16 leased homes against a cap of 16 under the attorney's rounding answer. The waiting list has five owners. March: a lease on Lot 22 ends and the owner moves back in. The permit lapses, and the secretary emails the offer to position 1 the next business day. Position 1 accepts in April, and the board posts the updated list. June: an owner on active duty receives orders and asks for a hardship lease. The board grants a 12-month permit under the hardship clause at its open meeting. The waiting list order does not change. September: a grandfathered Florida owner deeds the home to an LLC the owner controls. The board treats it as no change of ownership under 720.306(1)(h)4 and keeps the home grandfathered. December: a second director checks the roster against the forms, initials it, and the board reviews the procedure before the annual meeting.

Mistakes that sink a cap

Letting someone skip the line. A director's neighbor, or an owner who calls the president, gets the next slot. One documented skip is enough for every other owner on the list to argue the cap is not being enforced as written. Counting from memory. If you cannot produce a dated roster, you cannot tell an owner the cap is full. Screening the tenant. Asking for the lease application or a credit report crosses 209.016(b) in Texas, and it turns a cap into tenant approval anywhere. Applying a new Florida amendment to an owner who bought before it. Check the deed date before you send any letter. Fining first. When an owner leases without a slot, use your normal violation notice and hearing process, on the same schedule you use for every other violation. Forgetting to file. In Texas, an unfiled cap amendment or leasing rule has no effect under 202.006. Our guide on running a vote to amend the declaration covers the vote and the recording.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Reach every homeowner without a reply-all thread

Announcements with email notifications, an opt-in resident directory, neighbor messaging and a community website. Free to start.