OurHOA
Board & governance

A resident asked us to keep a specific person out of our gated HOA. What should the board do?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

How an HOA board handles a request to bar someone at the gate: protective orders, guest list changes, gate officer wording, trespass notices and privacy.

Part of the HOA board handbook: residents and communication.

The short answer

Act the same day on the part you control, which is the gate. Take the person off that household's guest list, shut off any remote, sticker, fob or code tied to them, and give whoever runs the gate a written instruction. Leave the restraining to the court and the police. A protective order binds the person named in it, not the association, and no gate stops someone who walks in behind a car. Most of these requests are simpler than they sound. A resident who wants an ex, a former roommate or an estranged relative off their own guest list needs no court order and no board vote. That is a routine change any household can make. The harder cases are a person who co-owns or leases the home, and a non-resident the board itself wants to bar for conduct on common property. Rules vary by state and by your declaration, bylaws and gate rules. This guide is general education, not legal advice. Call the association's attorney before barring anyone who is an owner, a tenant or another owner's guest.

What a protective order does and does not do

Read the order itself. The location terms decide what the police can act on, and many orders name the home but not the whole neighborhood. - Texas. Family Code 85.022(b)(3) lets a court bar a person from going to or near a protected person's residence, and 85.022(c) requires the court to describe each prohibited location and any minimum distance. Going to a place the order describes is an offense under Penal Code 25.07. - Florida. Section 741.30(6)(a)2. lets the court exclude the respondent from the petitioner's residence. Under 741.31(4)(a)2., going to or being within 500 feet of the petitioner's residence in willful violation of the injunction is a first-degree misdemeanor. - Colorado. C.R.S. 13-14-105(1)(c) and (d) let a court exclude a party from the family home or from another party's home on a showing that physical or emotional harm would otherwise result. - Other states. Under 18 U.S.C. 2265, a qualifying protection order from one state gets full faith and credit in another, so an order the resident brought from Arizona or Ohio is still enforced by your local police. None of these sections makes the gate officer an enforcer. Your gate may sit inside the 500 feet a Florida order covers, but nobody at the guardhouse should be measuring distances or deciding whether a violation happened. Their job is to refuse entry and call the police.

What to collect before you change the gate list

Use a one-page request form so every case gets the same treatment. Ask for: 1. The requesting resident's name, lot and best phone number. 2. The full name of the person to be refused, plus a photo, vehicle description and plate if the resident has them. 3. Whether there is a court order. If there is, the case number, the court, and the expiration date printed on it. A copy of the pages listing the parties, the protected locations and the dates is enough. The board does not need the whole file or the reasons. 4. Who in the household may add or remove guests from now on. 5. The resident's signature confirming the request and agreeing to tell the manager if the order is changed, extended or dropped. Then do the mechanical work: remove the name from that household's permanent guest list, deactivate any credential issued to that person, and change the household's call box or entry code. If the person ever had a key to the pool or clubhouse, add that to the list. Our guide on writing an amenity key, fob and gate code policy covers keeping one register so nothing gets missed.

Instructions for the gate officer

Give staff a short written instruction, not a story. Keep it to what they need at the window: "Do not admit [name] (photo and vehicle attached) to the community, including as a guest of any resident or as a passenger. Do not argue or explain. Tell the person you cannot admit them and ask them to leave. If they refuse, try to follow a vehicle in, or say they are there to see [resident], call 911 first, then call [resident] at [number]. Write the time, plate and what happened in the gate log. This instruction stays in effect until the manager removes it in writing." If your gate has no staff, say so to the resident in writing. A changed code and a deactivated remote help, but a call box cannot spot a face and tailgating is common. Suggest the resident give a copy of the order and a photo to the local police and, if the community has one, the patrol service. Do not write anything that reads like a promise the person will be kept out.

When the person is an owner, co-owner or tenant

Here the board stops taking one side's word. If the person to be refused is on the deed or on a lease the association has on file, they have the same access rights as any other resident until a court says otherwise. A spouse asking you to cut off the other spouse's fob during a divorce, with no order, is asking the association to pick a winner. Decline politely and suggest the resident ask the court. When there is an order, follow its terms. Texas Family Code 85.021(2) lets a court grant one party exclusive possession of a jointly owned or leased residence and direct the other to vacate. Florida 741.30(6)(a)2. and Colorado 13-14-105(1)(c) give courts similar power. An order like that supports deactivating the excluded person's credentials for that home. It does not always reach every common area, so ask the attorney before you bar an excluded co-owner from the pool or the annual meeting. Keep sending assessment notices and meeting notices the way your governing documents require. An owner who is excluded from the home is usually still an owner of record.

Barring a non-resident without a court order

Sometimes the board wants to bar someone itself: a former tenant who keeps coming back, a contractor who threatened staff, a visitor who damaged the clubhouse. That is possible only where the association owns or controls the property. Check the plat first. Some gated communities sit on streets dedicated to the city, and the board cannot bar anyone from a public street. Where the streets and amenities are association property, trespass law gives the owner a way to forbid entry: - Texas Penal Code 30.05(b)(2)(A) counts oral or written communication by the owner or someone with apparent authority to act for the owner as notice. - Florida 810.09(1)(a)1. covers a person who enters or remains after notice given by actual communication or by posting. - Colorado C.R.S. 18-4-201(3) says a person remains unlawfully when not licensed, invited or otherwise privileged, and 18-4-504 makes unlawful entry on another's premises third degree criminal trespass. Base the decision on documented conduct on common property, vote on it, and deliver the notice by hand or certified mail with a copy to the police non-emergency line. A sample motion: "Moved that the association, as owner of the common area streets and amenities, notify [name] in writing that entry onto association property is forbidden, based on the incidents of [dates] recorded in the incident log, with the board to review the notice in 12 months." The catch is guests. Most declarations let owners bring guests onto common areas. If another owner invites the barred person, the owner's rights and the board's notice collide, and that is a question for the attorney before it happens, not at the gate. Apply the same standard to everyone, too. A ban list built on who the board dislikes invites a fair housing complaint.

Privacy and a sample timeline

Keep the order and the request form in a restricted file that only the manager and the president can open. Gate staff get the name, photo, plate and instruction, nothing about why. If the board must discuss the case, do it in executive session where your state allows, and keep the minutes to "the board approved a gate access change for one household." Never post names in the newsletter or a community group. A workable timeline: - Day 0. Request received. Remove the name from the household list, deactivate credentials, change the household code. - Day 1. Written instruction to gate staff or patrol. Confirm the changes to the resident in writing. - Each incident. Gate log entry, police report number, a call to the resident. - 30 days before the order expires. Ask the resident whether it has been extended. If not, ask whether they still want the name off their list. - When the resident moves out. Remove the instruction and shred the copy of the order under your records policy.

Mistakes boards make

- Demanding a court order before taking a name off a resident's own guest list. - Cutting off a co-owner or tenant on one person's request, with no order. - Forwarding the order to the whole board, or describing the case in open-session minutes. - Telling staff to block a car or physically stop someone. Staff refuse entry and call 911. - Promising in writing that the person will be kept out. - Letting the instruction outlive the order, or the resident's time in the community. - Barring a non-resident for rudeness, or for reasons the board would not apply to anyone else. If the request comes with reports of threats or stalking inside the community, read our guide on what to do when a resident reports harassment by a neighbor, which covers logging incidents and pointing residents to the police and the courts.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Reach every homeowner without a reply-all thread

Announcements with email notifications, an opt-in resident directory, neighbor messaging and a community website. Free to start.