How does an HOA get a driver to pay for damage to a gate, wall or other common property?
By OurHOA · General information · Revised
How an HOA board recovers repair costs when a driver hits a gate, wall or sign: crash report, insurance claim, hit-and-run steps and TX, FL, CO small claims limits.
Part of the HOA board handbook: vendors, projects and upkeep.
The short answer
Get the police report number and the driver's insurance information, document the damage before anything is repaired, and file a property damage claim with the driver's auto insurer. The driver's property damage liability coverage exists to pay for exactly this kind of loss, so start there instead of with the association's own policy. When the driver is unknown, uninsured or underinsured, the association falls back on its own property policy and its deductible, and the board decides whether the gap is worth chasing in small claims court. The board's job is to move fast in the first few days, keep one person in charge of the file, and not let an insurer's delay turn into the association paying for someone else's crash. Laws differ by state and your governing documents may assign some of this work to a manager. This guide is general education, not legal advice.
The first 48 hours
Make the site safe first. Tape off a leaning wall, cap exposed wiring on a damaged light pole, and get a knocked-down stop sign back up or replaced with a temporary one the same day. Temporary work to prevent more damage is fine. Hold off on permanent repairs until the insurer's adjuster has seen the damage or signed off on your photos. Then collect evidence while it exists. Photograph the damage from several angles with something for scale, plus tire marks, debris and any vehicle parts left behind. Write down who called it in and when. Ask neighbors with doorbell cameras and check the association's own gate or pool cameras right away, because some systems record over footage within days. Save the clips to a board drive with the date and camera location. If police came, get the officer's name, agency and report number. If they didn't, call the non-emergency line and ask to file a report. The report is the document insurers ask for first.
Get the driver's information and the crash report
State law requires the driver to stop and identify themselves. In Texas, a driver whose crash damages only a structure, fixture or landscaping next to a highway must take reasonable steps to find and notify the owner with their name, address and plate number (Transportation Code section 550.025). Florida section 316.063 and Colorado C.R.S. 42-4-1604 require a driver who damages unattended property to stop and either notify the owner or leave a written notice with the same details, and Florida's version also requires notifying police. A driver who does this is usually cooperative. Ask for their auto insurer and policy number, and write the claim number down once they report it. The crash report lists the driver, vehicle and insurer. In Texas, the owner of property damaged in a crash can buy the officer's CR-3 report online from TxDOT for $6, or $8 certified. Florida section 316.066 keeps crash reports confidential for 60 days, with exceptions for the parties and their insurers. Ask the investigating agency whether the association qualifies as a party. In Colorado, request the report from the agency that responded.
Build the claim and send the demand
Get two written repair bids that describe the same scope. Expect the adjuster to question work beyond the damaged area, such as refinishing the undamaged half of a wall. Put the claim package together: the police report number, photos, both bids, any invoice for emergency work, and a short timeline. Send it to the driver's insurer under the claim number, with a copy to the driver. Watch the policy limits. The minimum property damage liability coverage is $25,000 per crash in Texas (Transportation Code section 601.072), $10,000 in Florida (section 324.022) and $15,000 in Colorado (C.R.S. 10-4-620). A masonry entry monument or a gate operator with a custom arm can cost more than a Florida minimum policy pays. Ask the adjuster for the limits early, and if the damage exceeds them, send the driver a separate demand for the difference. Demand letter wording: "On [date], a vehicle driven by [name] struck the [entry gate / wall / light pole] owned by [Association name] at [location], [police agency] report no. [ ]. Repair will cost $[ ] based on the enclosed bids, plus $[ ] for emergency work already done. Please confirm coverage and pay this claim within 30 days, or tell us in writing why you won't. Send payment to [Association name], [address]."
When the insurer stalls or the driver has no coverage
The association has no contract with the other driver's insurer, so it has fewer options there than with its own carrier. If the insurer denies the claim, sits on it or pays less than the repair costs, turn to the association's own property or package policy. The carrier pays the covered repair minus your deductible and then pursues the driver or the driver's insurer to get its money back. That process is called subrogation. If it recovers anything, you may get your deductible back. Our guide on whether to file an insurance claim or pay out of pocket covers the tradeoff for a small loss. When the uncovered amount is worth the effort, small claims court is the next step. The limit is $20,000 in a Texas justice court (Government Code section 27.031), $8,000 in Florida county court under Small Claims Rule 7.010, and $7,500 in Colorado small claims court (C.R.S. 13-6-403). Watch the calendar. Texas generally allows two years to sue for injury to property (Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.003). Florida allows two years for negligence claims (section 95.11). Colorado allows three years for motor vehicle property damage claims (C.R.S. 13-80-101(1)(n)).
Hit-and-run and unknown drivers
If nobody stopped, file the police report anyway, even when the agency won't investigate. Your insurer will want the report number, and a camera clip or a piece of bumper sometimes identifies the driver weeks later. Post a short notice asking owners who saw anything or have footage to contact the board. Then decide on the claim. If the repair costs less than the deductible, the association pays it from the operating or reserve budget as the budget allows. If it costs more, file with your own carrier. Notice to owners: "Sometime between [time] on [date] and [time] on [date], a vehicle struck the [entry wall] and left. If you saw it happen or have camera footage from that window, please contact [name] at [email] before [date]. The board will share any footage only with police and the association's insurer."
When the driver is an owner, tenant or guest
The steps are the same. Start with the driver's auto insurer, because that policy exists to pay for this. If the insurer won't pay and the driver is an owner, or an owner's tenant or guest, your declaration may let the association charge the repair cost to that owner's account as a reimbursement assessment. Our guide on whether an HOA can bill you for damage you caused explains how that works and the notice and hearing rights that still apply. Don't label it a fine, and don't skip the hearing your documents or state law require.
Mistakes boards make, and a motion to copy
Repairing the gate before anyone photographs it. Waiting a week to ask for camera footage that has already been recorded over. Letting a board member take the driver's word that they'll "just pay for it" with no insurer or claim number. Accepting the first low offer without a second bid. Forgetting the deductible, which often becomes the only amount the association actually loses. Letting the limitations date slip while the insurer drags its feet. Motion for the minutes: "I move that the board authorize [name] to handle the claim for damage to the [entry gate] on [date], to approve emergency repairs up to $[ ], to obtain two repair bids, to file a claim with the driver's insurer and, if needed, with the association's property insurer, and to report back at the next meeting."
Sources
- Texas Transportation Code chapter 550 (section 550.025: duty on striking a structure or fixture)
- Texas Transportation Code chapter 601 (section 601.072: minimum coverage)
- Texas Government Code chapter 27 (section 27.031: justice court jurisdiction)
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 16 (section 16.003)
- TxDOT: crash reports and records
- Texas Department of Insurance: how to deal with the other driver's insurance
- Florida Statutes 316.063: duty upon damaging unattended vehicle or other property (2026)
- Florida Statutes 316.066: crash reports (2026)
- Florida Statutes 324.022: financial responsibility for property damage (2026)
- Florida Statutes 95.11: limitations periods (2026)
- Florida Small Claims Rules, July 1, 2026 (Rule 7.010) (PDF)
- Colorado Revised Statutes 2026, title 42 (section 42-4-1604)
- Colorado Revised Statutes 2026, title 10 (section 10-4-620)
- Colorado Revised Statutes 2026, title 13 (sections 13-6-403 and 13-80-101)
These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.
More from the board handbook
- How do we write an HOA request for proposal and compare contractor bids?
- What should an HOA board check in a vendor contract before signing it?
- How do we read a vendor's certificate of insurance (ACORD 25) before work starts?
- What should go in an HOA board's emergency preparedness plan?
- How do we plan a major HOA project like a roof replacement or repaving?
- What should be on an HOA preventive maintenance schedule, season by season?
- How do we write clear HOA architectural guidelines from our CC&Rs?
- How should an HOA board inspect its playground and pool for safety hazards?
- How should an HOA board choose an insurance agent and read the renewal quote?
- How should an HOA board prepare for a reserve study site visit?
- How do we set up a key, fob and gate code policy for our HOA's amenities?
- How do we write an HOA snow removal contract?
- How do we plan a tree maintenance program for our HOA's common areas?
- How does an HOA board get the community pool ready to open for the season?
- How do we run an HOA volunteer work day without taking on too much risk?
- What should an HOA board do when a vendor is not doing the work it was hired to do?
- How do we replace the cluster mailboxes in our HOA?
- How do we cut our HOA's common area water bill with an irrigation audit?
- How do we replace our HOA's entrance monument sign?
- How do we set up pet waste stations and a dog area in our HOA?
- How do we handle an HOA insurance claim after a storm, step by step?
- How do we hire a landscaping contractor for our HOA and write the scope?
- How do we set up security cameras in our HOA's common areas?
- What should our HOA board do and write down after someone is hurt in a common area?
- How do we set up a maintenance schedule for our HOA retention or detention pond?
- What should our HOA board do when a sinkhole or ground collapse opens in the common area?
- How do we convert our HOA streetlights to LED?
- How do we plan a repaving and sealcoat program for our HOA's private streets?
- How does an HOA board bid out trash and recycling service for the community?
- How do we plan an HOA pool resurfacing or replaster project?
- How do we set up a termite and pest control contract for our HOA?
- How do we replace our HOA's perimeter fence or screening wall?
- How do we maintain and repair our HOA's automatic entry gate?
- How does an HOA board run a sidewalk trip hazard repair program?
- How do we set up an annual backflow testing program for our HOA's irrigation?
- How do we plan an exterior repainting project for our HOA's townhomes or buildings?
- How does an HOA board plan a playground equipment replacement?
- How do we plan an HOA clubhouse renovation?
- How do we set up a mosquito control program for our HOA?
- How do we run an HOA storm debris cleanup after a hurricane or hail storm?
- How do we plan an HOA tennis court resurfacing and decide whether to add pickleball lines?
- How do we set up a wildfire defensible space program for our HOA's common areas?
- How do we run a bulk trash or dumpster day for our HOA?
- How do we inspect and repair a retaining wall our HOA maintains?
- How do we schedule fire extinguisher and fire alarm inspections for our HOA?
- How do we winterize HOA irrigation and keep common-area pipes from freezing?
- How do we fix standing water and drainage problems in our HOA common areas?
- How does an HOA run a dryer vent cleaning program for condos and townhomes?
- How do we hire a contractor to put up holiday lights at the HOA entrance?
- How do we bid janitorial service for the HOA clubhouse and pool restrooms?
- What should our HOA board do when water leaks from a common element into a unit?
- What should an HOA board do when a contractor files a lien on common area?
- How do we hire a reserve study company for our HOA?
- How do we replace or add a fountain or aerator in our HOA pond?
- How do we set up an AED program for our HOA clubhouse or pool?
- How do we replace the fence and gates around our HOA pool?
- How do we add EV chargers to HOA common area parking?
- What should our HOA board do when sewage backs up from a common sewer line?
- How do we replace the pump or heater on our HOA pool?
- What should our HOA board do about a gas leak at the clubhouse or pool heater?
- How do we replace the pool furniture at our HOA pool?
- How do we hire a pressure washing contractor for our HOA common areas?
- How do we replace the heating and air conditioning system in our HOA clubhouse?
- How do we plan a dredging project for our HOA's stormwater or retention pond?
- How do we close out an HOA construction project and release retainage?
- How do we hire a roofer to replace an HOA clubhouse or condo building roof?
- How do we replace the concrete or pavers on our HOA pool deck?
- How do we hire a land surveyor to mark our HOA's common area boundaries?
- How do we hire a gutter cleaning contractor for our HOA condo or townhome buildings?
- How do we hire a window washing contractor for our HOA condo buildings?
- How do we run a chimney and fireplace inspection program for our HOA condo buildings?
- How do we plan a siding replacement for our HOA's condo or townhome buildings?
- How do we replace the exterior stairs on our HOA condo buildings?
- How do we replace failed sealant and caulking on our HOA buildings?
- How do we hire an elevator maintenance contractor for our HOA building?
- How do we repair cracked stucco on our HOA's condo or townhome buildings?
- How do we replace the balcony railings on our HOA condo buildings?
- How do we repair the concrete deck in our HOA parking garage?
- How do we repair an eroding pond bank in our HOA?
- How do we replace the hallway carpet or flooring in our condo building?
- How should our HOA board handle a bed bug report in a condo building?
- How do we replace a failing stormwater outlet structure or culvert in our HOA?
- How should an HOA board handle a state dam safety inspection of its pond embankment?
- How do we replace the pump station that irrigates our HOA common areas from a lake or pond?
- How do we replace a failing sewer lift station pump in our HOA?
- How does an HOA board run its own community water system?
- How do we maintain a shared septic system our HOA owns?
- What should our HOA board do when mold shows up in a common area?
- A utility or fiber company wants an easement across our HOA common area. How should the board respond?
- How do we negotiate a bulk internet or cable agreement for our HOA?
- How do we restripe our HOA parking lot and mark accessible parking spaces correctly?
- What should an HOA board do when a contractor abandons a project?
- What should our HOA board do about vandalism or graffiti on common property?
- How should an HOA board respond when the city cites the association for a code violation on common property?
- How do we add speed humps or other traffic calming on our private HOA streets?
- How do we maintain and test our HOA's emergency generator?
- How do we replace the windows in our condo building, and who pays for them?
- What should our HOA board do about fire ants, wasp nests or a bee swarm on common area?
- How do we replace the fire alarm panel in our HOA building?
- How does an HOA board stop trespassers from using the pool or clubhouse?
- How should an HOA board respond to coyote sightings or aggressive wildlife?
- How should an HOA board handle a homeless encampment on common area?
- How do we ask the city or county to take over our HOA's private streets?
- How do we convert our HOA's common area grass to water-wise landscaping?
- How does an HOA board add package lockers for residents?
- What should an HOA board do when the master insurance policy is not renewed?
- A utility or cable crew is digging on our HOA common area and nobody told us. What should the board do?