How does our Florida HOA deal with feral Muscovy ducks on the common areas?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised October 29, 2026

How a Florida HOA board handles feral Muscovy ducks: the federal control order, FWC trapping rules, no relocation, nest control, feeding rules and owner conflict.

Part of the HOA board handbook: vendors, projects and upkeep.

The short answer

Feral Muscovy ducks are a nonnative species in Florida, and federal rules let an association remove them, their nests and their eggs on its own land without a permit. The catch is what happens next. A captured Muscovy cannot be released anywhere else, so removal means the birds are euthanized humanely or donated to a public museum or educational institution. That fact drives most of the owner conflict, and the board should say it plainly before it votes. The workable plan has three parts: stop the feeding that keeps the flock large, cut down nesting so the numbers stop climbing, and hire a licensed nuisance wildlife trapper if the flock is already too big for the first two to fix. Rules vary by state and by your governing documents, and this guide is education, not legal advice.

What the law allows

Wild Muscovy ducks are covered by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, but the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service carved out a control order for them at 50 CFR 21.174. Anywhere in the lower 48 except Hidalgo, Starr and Zapata counties in Texas, landowners and their tenants, employees or agents may remove or destroy Muscovy ducks, hybrids of Muscovy ducks, and their nests or eggs at any time, with no federal permit. On common areas the association is the landowner, and a contractor it hires acts as its agent. The same rule sets limits. Removed birds may be donated to public museums or public institutions for scientific or educational use, or buried or incinerated. Nobody may keep one for personal use, eat it, sell it, or release it somewhere else. Anyone using a firearm must use nontoxic shot, and if a protected species is taken by mistake it must be reported to the Fish and Wildlife Service's Ecological Services office. Florida adds its own layer. Section 379.231, Florida Statutes, makes it unlawful to release any nonnative animal in the state without FWC authorization. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) says it does not remove nuisance Muscovy ducks itself, that no permit is needed to remove them by humane live capture, and that traps must be checked at least once every 24 hours with any non-target animal released on site. Florida's animal cruelty law, section 828.12, still applies to how birds are handled and killed: unnecessary or cruel killing is a crime. The FWC allows shooting on private property in daylight with landowner permission, but city and county firearm ordinances usually rule it out in a neighborhood, so plan on trapping.

Step 1: Stop the feeding

Feeding is why a pond with six ducks becomes a pond with sixty. The FWC flyer says never to feed Muscovy ducks, by hand or by leaving feed where they can reach it, and notes that natural food is plentiful. University of Florida extension researchers add that fed Muscovies are often aggressive and may chase or try to bite children, and that their droppings degrade water quality. University of Florida researchers note that many cities, particularly in South Florida, ban duck feeding, so check your city and county code first and cite it in your notice. If your declaration lets the board adopt rules for common areas, adopt a no-feeding rule. A rule the board can copy: "No person may feed Muscovy ducks or other waterfowl on any common area, or place food, seed, bread or pet food where waterfowl can reach it from a common area. Violations are subject to the association's fining procedure." Put signs at the pond and along the walking path. Pair the rule with something owners can do: spray ducks with a garden hose, or let a leashed dog move them along without catching them. The FWC suggests both. Our guide on stopping residents from feeding ducks and geese at the HOA pond covers sign wording and habitat changes in more depth.

Step 2: Control nesting

Feral Muscovies nest in shallow scrapes on the ground, often in mulch beds, under shrubs and against buildings. According to the University of Florida fact sheet, a hen lays 8 to 16 eggs and incubates them for about five weeks. The same fact sheet gives the method: do not remove the eggs, because the hen will lay a replacement clutch. Shake each egg hard so it will not develop and put it back in the nest, or swap the eggs for plastic ones. The hen keeps sitting on eggs that never hatch, which uses up her season. The federal control order covers this work, so the landscape contractor or a trained volunteer can do it as the association's agent. Write it into the landscape contract: crews report any nest they find in a common bed within one business day, and the board's designated person treats it within three days. Keep a nest log with the date, location, egg count and who treated it. Before touching a nest, confirm it belongs to a Muscovy; the control order does not cover native ducks, and taking those requires federal authorization.

Step 3: Hire a trapper if the flock is already large

When feeding rules and nest control will take years to bring numbers down, removal is the remaining tool. The FWC keeps a county-by-county list of nuisance wildlife trappers, and some of them remove Muscovy ducks for a fee. Get two quotes. Ask each trapper: 1. How do you capture the birds (cage traps, funnel traps or nets), and how often do you check traps? The FWC minimum is once every 24 hours. 2. What happens to the birds after capture, and where? Get the answer in writing. 3. How do you avoid catching native ducks, wading birds and pets, and what do you do if you catch one? 4. Do you carry liability insurance, and will you name the association as an additional insured? The written answer to question 2 matters most. If a trapper says the birds go to a farm or sanctuary, ask for the name and confirm it is a public museum or public institution for scientific or educational use. Anything else is release, which the federal rule and section 379.231 forbid. A sample motion: "I move that the board hire [trapper] to remove up to [number] feral Muscovy ducks from the association's common areas between [dates], at a cost not to exceed $[amount], in compliance with 50 CFR 21.174 and FWC guidance, with disposition of all birds documented in writing."

Handling the owner conflict

Some owners will be glad. Others will be upset, and a few feed the ducks precisely because they like them. Do these things before any trapping: - Discuss removal at an open board meeting with notice that names the topic. Let owners speak. - Explain in writing why relocation is not an option, citing the federal rule and the state statute. Most opposition assumes the birds could simply be moved. - Share the facts the board relied on: complaint counts, photos of droppings on walkways, any bites or chasing incidents, and pond water quality concerns. - Give the feeding rule and nest program at least one nesting season before trapping, unless the flock is causing injuries. A notice paragraph the board can adapt: "Feral Muscovy ducks are a nonnative species. Federal and Florida law prohibit relocating or releasing them. The board will vote on [date] on a plan to end feeding on common areas, treat nests, and, if needed, hire a licensed trapper to reduce the flock humanely. Comments are welcome at the meeting or in writing to [address] by [date]." The association manages the common areas, but individual owners decide what happens on their own lots. If ducks nest on a private lot, the owner, not the association, chooses whether to act, unless your declaration says otherwise.

Enforcing the feeding rule

In Florida, section 720.305 sets the fining process for HOAs. Unless your documents say otherwise, a fine cannot exceed $100 per violation, and daily fines for a continuing violation cap at $1,000 in total. Before any fine, the board must give the owner at least 14 days' written notice of the right to a hearing. A committee of at least three owners who are not officers, directors, employees or their close relatives holds the hearing within 90 days, and the fine stands only if a majority of the committee approves it. Start with a friendly letter and photos. Save fines for repeat violators, and document dates and times.

Sample timeline and common mistakes

Month 1: count the flock, log complaints and photograph problem areas. Check city and county code for a feeding ban. Month 2: adopt the no-feeding rule at an open meeting, mail the notice and post signs. Months 2 to 3: amend the landscape contract to add nest reporting and start the nest log. Month 6: recount. If numbers have not leveled off, or if there are injuries, get trapper quotes and vote at an open meeting. Mistakes boards make: - Promising to "relocate" the ducks. It is illegal, and the promise becomes a broken one. - Pulling eggs out of nests, which only prompts the hen to lay again. - Letting a volunteer trap and dispose of birds. Use a licensed trapper so handling is humane and documented. - Treating a native duck's nest as a Muscovy's. - Trapping without telling owners. The backlash usually costs more than the ducks. - Fining feeders without the 14-day notice and committee hearing. If Canada geese share the pond, our guide on managing Canada geese with egg addling explains the separate federal registration that geese require.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More on living with an hoa

Or browse all living with an hoa guides.