OurHOA
Dues & money

How does an HOA board collect the depreciation the insurer held back on a claim?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

How an HOA board collects recoverable depreciation after an insurance claim: proof of repair, policy deadlines, deductible proof, and TX, FL, CO and CA rules.

Part of the HOA board handbook: vendors, projects and upkeep.

The short answer

On a replacement cost policy, the first check usually pays actual cash value: the cost to replace the damaged property minus depreciation for age and wear, minus the deductible. The depreciation the insurer kept back, often called recoverable depreciation or the holdback, gets paid only after the association repairs or replaces the property and proves it. To collect it, the board has to find the policy's deadline, finish the work, pay the deductible, and send the insurer a clean package of invoices, proof of payment and photos before the clock runs out. Miss the deadline and the association can be left with actual cash value only, and the gap becomes a cost the owners carry. Rules vary by state, by the policy and by your governing documents. This guide is general education, not legal advice.

How the numbers work

Say hail ruins the roofs on four buildings. The adjuster prices the replacement at $180,000. The roofs are 14 years old, so the adjuster depreciates them to an actual cash value of $120,000. The policy has a $25,000 deductible. First check: $120,000 minus $25,000, or $95,000. Held back: $180,000 minus $120,000, or $60,000. Full recovery after the work is done: $95,000 plus $60,000, or $155,000, which is replacement cost minus the deductible. That $60,000 is a third of what the insurer owes, and the association only gets it by doing the work and asking for it. The Texas Department of Insurance explains the same split to homeowners: the first check is likely actual cash value, and the rest follows once repairs start and the policyholder shows proof. If the final invoice comes in lower than the adjuster's estimate, expect the holdback to shrink to match what was actually spent. If it comes in higher, send the change orders and ask for a supplement, since most replacement cost policies pay what the repair reasonably cost, up to the limit.

Find the deadline and conditions in the policy

Open the master policy to the valuation or loss settlement condition, usually under a heading like Replacement Cost or Optional Coverages, and write down four things: 1. The time limit to complete repairs or claim the replacement cost, and when it starts (date of loss, or date of the first payment). 2. Whether the policy requires written notice of intent to claim replacement cost within a set number of days after the loss. Some commercial forms do, and a board that cashes the first check without sending that notice can lose the holdback. 3. Whether the repair must be at the same site and of like kind and quality. 4. What proof the insurer wants: final invoices, lien waivers, proof of payment, photos, a certificate of completion or a final inspection. State law sets floors in some places, but mostly for homeowner policies, not association master policies. California Insurance Code section 2051.5(b) bars a limit shorter than 12 months from the first actual cash value payment, or 36 months for a loss tied to a declared state of emergency. Colorado's 36-month window in C.R.S. 10-4-110.8(13)(b) covers homeowner's policies after a total loss from a declared wildfire disaster, and the section's definition of owner-occupied residence excludes property insured under a commercial policy. Florida's section 627.7011(3)(a) is written for homeowner's policies, and section 627.4025(1) classifies condominium association and HOA common-element coverage as commercial lines residential coverage. So in most cases the master policy's own wording sets the deadline. Read it the week the first check arrives.

The steps, in order

1. When the first check arrives, put it in a separate claim account or a separate ledger line so the proceeds aren't mixed into operating funds. 2. Send any required notice of intent to claim replacement cost, in writing, with the claim number. 3. Calendar the policy deadline with two reminders: 90 days out and 30 days out. 4. Get bids, sign a contract that matches the adjuster's scope, and ask the contractor to flag anything that adds scope early, so the insurer can approve it before the work. 5. Pay the deductible portion and keep the proof. If the board funds it by special assessment, our guide on levying an insurance deductible assessment after a loss covers that process. 6. When the work is done, collect the final invoice, a final lien waiver from the contractor and major suppliers, proof of each payment, and dated after photos taken from the same angles as the adjuster's photos. 7. Send the request letter below with the package. Keep a copy of everything sent. 8. Follow up in writing if no answer comes within 15 business days, and log every call. If the work will run past the deadline because of permits, material shortages or contractor backlogs, ask the insurer for an extension in writing before the deadline, explain the cause, and attach the signed contract and schedule. Get the extension in writing, not by phone.

Texas, Florida and Colorado rules that matter

Texas. Insurance Code section 707.004 lets an insurer refuse to pay withheld recoverable depreciation or a replacement cost holdback until it receives reasonable proof that the policyholder paid the deductible. The statute lists what counts: a canceled check, a money order receipt, a credit card statement, or an executed installment or financing contract that pays the deductible in full over time. Section 707.002 says the insured must pay any deductible on a first-party property claim. Once the association has done what the policy requires, section 542.057(b) says that when payment depends on an act by the claimant, the insurer pays within five business days after the act is performed (20 business days for an eligible surplus lines insurer). For condominiums, Property Code section 82.111(f) says proceeds are held in trust and spent first on repair, and section 82.111(i) requires prompt repair unless an exception applies. Florida. Section 718.111(11)(j) makes the association repair insured condominium property damaged by an insurable event as a common expense, and makes damages beyond insurance coverage a common expense too, with exceptions in the statute. A holdback the board fails to collect turns into that kind of shortfall, paid by every owner. Colorado. C.R.S. 38-33.3-313(5) says covered losses are adjusted with the association, proceeds are held in trust and disbursed first for repair. Section 38-33.3-313(9) requires prompt repair of insured property unless an exception applies, and makes repair costs beyond insurance proceeds and reserves a common expense.

A request letter the board can adapt

Have an officer sign it and send it by a method that proves delivery: 'Re: Claim [number], policy [number], date of loss [date]. The Association has completed the repairs covered by this claim. The work was finished on [date] by [contractor], for a total cost of $[amount]. Enclosed are the final invoice, the contractor's final lien waiver, proof of payment for each draw, proof that the Association paid the $[amount] deductible, and photos of the completed work. Your actual cash value payment of $[amount] was received on [date]. Please release the remaining replacement cost of $[amount], which is the withheld depreciation shown on your estimate dated [date], adjusted for the actual cost of the work. If you need anything else to process this payment, please list it in writing within 10 days.' Attach the insurer's estimate page that shows the depreciation line by line, so the adjuster doesn't have to go looking for it.

A sample timeline

Month 0: hail on May 2. Claim reported May 3. Month 2: the adjuster's estimate arrives and the first check of $95,000 is deposited to the claim account on July 10. The treasurer calendars the policy's replacement cost deadline, finds the required notice of intent, and sends it that week. Month 3: bids come in, the board votes, the contract is signed. Month 5: the roofer finishes all four buildings. The deductible assessment has been collected and the association has paid the roofer in full. Month 6: the request package goes out. Two weeks later the adjuster asks for one missing lien waiver, which goes out the same day. Month 7: the $60,000 holdback check arrives, the treasurer reconciles the claim ledger, and the board reports the final numbers to owners at the next meeting.

Mistakes boards make

Treating the first check as the final payment and closing the file. Spending the first check on unrelated projects, then lacking cash to finish the repair that triggers the holdback. Letting the contractor's scope drift from the adjuster's estimate without telling the insurer, then arguing about it after the work is done. Paying the contractor without getting lien waivers. Waiting for the last invoice before starting the package, then finding that the policy deadline passed during a permit delay nobody reported. And letting a contractor offer to absorb the deductible, which Texas Business and Commerce Code section 27.02 prohibits for contractors and which can sink the holdback under section 707.004. If the insurer's estimate itself looks too low, our guide on using the appraisal clause when an HOA insurance claim is underpaid covers the dispute step, and our guide on handling an HOA insurance claim after a storm covers the claim from day one.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Track every request from report to done

Assign maintenance requests to a board member, email vendors a work order with photos, and keep the history. Free to start.