OurHOA
Dues & money

Our insurer's estimate is far below our bids. How does an HOA board use the policy's appraisal clause?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

How an HOA board uses the appraisal clause when the insurer's estimate is too low: the demand letter, choosing an appraiser, the umpire, costs, and TX, FL and CO rules.

Part of the HOA board handbook: vendors, projects and upkeep.

The short answer

When the carrier agrees the damage is covered but its number is far below what contractors will charge, look for an appraisal clause in the master policy. Most property policies have one. Either side can demand appraisal in writing. Each side picks an appraiser, the two appraisers pick an umpire, and a written award signed by any two of the three sets the amount of loss. It is usually faster and cheaper than a lawsuit, and the award binds both sides on the amount. It does not decide whether something is covered. Before the board sends a demand, read the clause, calendar any deadline in it, and talk to association counsel if the carrier has denied any part of the claim. Rules vary by state and by the policy wording, so treat this as background for that conversation, not legal advice. Our guide on how to handle an HOA insurance claim after a storm covers the claim up to this point.

What appraisal settles and what it leaves alone

Appraisal answers one question: what the covered loss costs. California's standard fire policy in Insurance Code section 2071 puts it plainly. When the insured and the company fail to agree on actual cash value or the amount of loss, either may ask in writing for appraisal, and the appraisers state actual cash value and loss for each item. Texas wrote the same limit into Insurance Code chapter 1813. Section 1813.003(b) describes appraisal as a process solely to determine the amount of loss, and section 1813.004(a) says an appraisal does not affect any applicable policy terms. So the award is a dollar figure, and the carrier then applies the policy to it. The deductible still comes off, a replacement cost policy may still hold back depreciation until the work is done, and the umpire does not rule on an exclusion such as wear and tear. If the real fight is whether hail or age ruined the roof, expect the carrier to call it a coverage question, and bring in counsel.

Read the clause and your state's rules first

Get the full certified policy from the agent and find the appraisal condition. Note five things: who can demand it, whether the demand must be in writing, any deadline to demand it, how many days each side has to name an appraiser, and what happens if the appraisers can't agree on an umpire. California's standard form gives 20 days to name an appraiser and 15 days to agree on an umpire, after which either side can ask a judge to pick one. Your policy may use different numbers. Texas. Chapter 1813, added by SB 458 in 2025, requires an appraisal provision in personal auto and residential property policies delivered, issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2026. Section 1813.001(b) excludes commercial policies and TWIA policies. Most association master policies are written as commercial policies, so don't assume the new chapter applies; if the clause is in your policy, the contract gives you the right. Coastal associations with a TWIA windstorm policy should move fast. The Texas Department of Insurance warns that on some TWIA policies the deadline to demand appraisal is 60 days after TWIA's estimate. Colorado has no statute that requires appraisal or sets its procedure. HB26-1247, a 2026 bill that would have required binding appraisal in homeowner's policies, was postponed indefinitely in committee on March 25, 2026. The policy wording controls.

Florida: mediation and the presuit notice

Florida section 627.7015 sets up a mediation program, run through the Department of Financial Services, for disputed property claims before appraisal or a lawsuit. It covers personal lines and commercial residential policies, and section 627.4025(1) counts condominium association policies and policies covering the common elements of a homeowners association as commercial residential coverage. The insurer pays for the conference, and the disputed amount must be at least $500 unless both sides agree to less. Under subsection (7), if the insurer never told you about the program, as it must at issue, renewal and claim filing, or if the insurer asked for mediation and either side rejected the result, the association does not have to go through contractual appraisal before suing for breach of contract. And under subsection (6), a mediated settlement can be rescinded within 3 business days unless the association has already cashed or deposited the check. If the dispute heads toward court, section 627.70152 requires written notice of intent to sue, filed through the department, at least 10 business days before filing. When the dispute is not a denial, the insurer must answer within 10 business days with a settlement offer or by requiring appraisal or another form of dispute resolution. If that is not finished within 90 days after the notice period ends, the association may file. So even a board that skips appraisal can land in it at that stage.

The steps, in order

1. Get the carrier's itemized estimate and send a supplement first, with your contractor's measurements and photos. 2. Put two or three bids on the same scope next to it and list the differences line by line. 3. Have counsel read the clause and any partial denial letter and answer one question: is this an amount dispute or a coverage dispute? 4. Vote at a properly noticed board meeting to demand appraisal and hire an appraiser, with a spending limit. In Texas, Property Code section 209.0051(c) lets the board go into closed executive session to talk with the association's attorney or discuss threatened litigation, but the meeting itself must be open. Take the vote in the open part. 5. Send the written demand the way the policy's notice condition requires, and keep proof of delivery. 6. Name your appraiser inside the clause's deadline. Note the date the carrier names theirs. 7. The appraisers choose an umpire. If they can't, follow the clause, which often lets either side ask a court to appoint one. 8. The appraisers inspect, trade estimates and settle what they can. Only the items they can't agree on go to the umpire. 9. The signed award goes to the carrier, which pays it under the policy terms.

Choosing the association's appraiser and paying for it

Look for someone who prices repairs on buildings like yours for a living, such as a construction estimator or roofing consultant who has done appraisal work locally. Ask about recent appraisals they handled, how many ended in an umpire award, and whether they can price the job in the same estimate format the carrier used, which speeds the line-by-line comparison. Many clauses, California's among them, require each appraiser to be competent and disinterested. An appraiser paid a percentage of the award has a stake in the result, which hands the carrier an argument against the award. Pay hourly or a flat fee, in a signed engagement letter. The association pays its own appraiser and splits the umpire's fee and other appraisal costs equally with the carrier, as California's section 2071 provides and the Texas Department of Insurance tells policyholders. A gap of a few thousand dollars may not cover those fees. A six-figure gap on a hail-damaged roof usually will.

Wording the board can adapt

Have counsel review the letter before it goes out. A motion: "I move that the association demand appraisal under the appraisal condition of policy number [number] for claim number [number], that the board engage [name] as the association's appraiser at [rate], not to exceed $[amount] without further board approval, and that the president sign the demand and the engagement letter." A demand letter: "[Association name] and [carrier] disagree on the amount of loss for claim number [number], date of loss [date]. Under the appraisal provision of policy number [number], the association demands appraisal of the amount of loss. The association names [appraiser name and contact information] as its appraiser. Please name your appraiser in writing within the time the policy allows. This demand does not waive any right of the association under the policy or the law." For owners, one line in the next update is enough: the board has started the appraisal process in the policy, independent appraisers will set the amount, and protective repairs continue in the meantime.

A sample timeline

Week 0: the carrier's final estimate arrives, well below the lowest roof bid. Week 1: counsel reads the clause and the board notices a meeting. Week 2: the board votes, and the demand goes out naming the association's appraiser. Week 4: the carrier names its appraiser. Week 6: the appraisers agree on an umpire. Weeks 6 to 10: joint inspection, then estimates traded line by line. Weeks 10 to 16: most items agreed, a handful sent to the umpire. Week 18: the signed award reaches the carrier. Weeks 19 to 22: payment, less the deductible and any depreciation holdback. Your clause and your carrier will change every number here. The order rarely changes.

Mistakes boards make

Using appraisal for a coverage fight. If the carrier says the damage is excluded, an umpire can't fix that, and the association can spend months and real money to get a number the carrier still won't pay. Missing the window. A deadline in the clause, or the 60-day limit on some TWIA policies, can end the right to appraisal. Calendar it the day the estimate arrives. Letting the dispute stall work that stops further damage. Tarps and dry-out can't wait for an award, and most policies require the association to protect the property. Promising owners the award amount. The check is the award minus the deductible and any depreciation holdback. Deciding by email. Vote at a noticed meeting and record it in the minutes.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Track every request from report to done

Assign maintenance requests to a board member, email vendors a work order with photos, and keep the history. Free to start.