OurHOA
Dues & money

Should our HOA hire a public adjuster for an insurance claim, and how do we vet one?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

When an HOA board should hire a public adjuster, how to check the license, read the contract and fee, and the TX, FL and CO rules on caps and cancellation.

Part of the HOA board handbook: vendors, projects and upkeep.

The short answer

A public adjuster is a licensed claims professional who works for the association, not the insurer, and is paid out of the settlement. Hiring one makes sense when the loss is large, the insurer's estimate sits well below your contractor bids, or no volunteer has the hours to run a claim that may last six months. For a small claim the insurer is paying fairly, the fee just comes off money you would have received anyway. If the board decides to hire, do four things before anyone signs: confirm the license with the state, get the fee written as a number you can test against real dollars, read the contract for cancellation rights and conflicts, and approve the contract by board vote. Fee caps and cancellation windows vary by state, and your policy and governing documents add terms of their own. Treat this as general education, and bring in association counsel for a disputed or high-dollar claim.

When a public adjuster earns the fee

Look at the gap, not the total. If the insurer offers $180,000 and two contractors price the repair at $260,000, an adjuster who closes most of that $80,000 gap pays for the hire even after a 10 percent fee on the whole settlement. If the insurer offers $180,000 and your bids come in at $190,000, the fee will likely eat the difference. The Texas Department of Insurance spells out the trap with its own example: if the insurer will pay $100,000 and you dispute $20,000, the adjuster could charge $10,000, because the fee can be figured on the total settlement, not just the disputed part. TDI also warns that you may still owe the fee if the insurer never raises its offer. Good reasons to hire: a multi-building wind or hail loss, water damage hidden in walls, a claim with business interruption or code upgrade questions, or a board where the only volunteer with time is moving out. A weak reason: a roofer at the gate who "knows a guy." A denial on coverage grounds is a legal question. Florida's section 626.854(3) bars public adjusters from giving legal advice, so a coverage denial points to counsel first.

Check the license and the person

Every state discussed here requires a license, and the license belongs to a person, so check the individual who will work your claim as well as the firm. Texas. Insurance Code section 4102.051 requires a TDI license. TDI's consumer page says to call its Help Line at 800-252-3439 to confirm the license and ask about complaints and disciplinary actions. Florida. The Department of Financial Services tells consumers to ask for the license number, compare it to the adjuster's photo ID, and look it up on its Licensee Search at licenseesearch.fldfs.com. Section 626.854(20) bars anyone but a licensed public adjuster or an attorney from negotiating a claim for pay. Colorado. Section 10-2-417 requires a license, requires a business entity acting as a public adjuster to hold its own license, and requires a surety bond of at least $20,000 for the life of the license. Ask for the license number and bond, then confirm both with the Division of Insurance. Then vet them like any vendor: three references from community associations, not single-family homes, a sample finished estimate, and how many open claims the adjuster is carrying now.

Read the fee clause with real numbers

Ask each candidate to fill in the fee clause against your claim before you compare them. Write the insurer's current offer, the expected settlement and the fee in dollars side by side. TDI notes you can ask for the fee as a dollar amount instead of a percentage. Texas. Section 4102.104 allows an hourly fee, a flat rate, a percentage or another method, but the total may not exceed 10 percent of the settlement. If the insurer pays or commits in writing to pay the policy limit within 72 hours after the loss is reported, the adjuster can't take a percentage and is limited to reasonable compensation for time and expenses. Florida. Section 626.854(11) caps the fee at 10 percent of claim payments for claims made in the year after a governor's state of emergency declaration and 20 percent otherwise. The adjuster gets nothing on money the insurer paid or agreed in writing to pay before the contract was signed, and nothing on the deductible. For a reopened or supplemental claim, the fee may be figured only on new money the adjuster brings in, up to 20 percent. These limits sit in subsections that section 626.854(19) applies to residential policies, and section 627.4025 defines residential coverage to include policies on condominium association buildings and HOA common elements. Confirm with counsel that your policy fits before you rely on the cap. Colorado. Section 10-2-417(4) caps the fee at 10 percent after a catastrophic disaster, and the same subsection bars any fee, retainer or deposit before the claim settles. Outside a disaster, the fee is whatever the contract says, so negotiate it.

Contract terms to insist on

Read the contract against this list before the vote. - Cancellation. Texas section 4102.103 requires a state-approved contract form that lets the association rescind by written notice within 72 hours of signing and prints "WE REPRESENT THE INSURED ONLY" in bold. Florida section 626.854(7) allows cancellation within 10 days of signing, or for a declared emergency, 30 days after the date of loss if that is later, and the notice goes by certified mail or another method with proof of mailing. Colorado section 10-2-417(6)(i)(IV) allows rescission by mail to both the insurer and the adjuster within 72 hours of signing. - No repair role. Texas sections 4102.158 and 4102.163 and Colorado section 10-2-417(6)(g) bar the adjuster from taking part in repairs on the claim, and Texas bars contractors from acting as public adjusters on property they may repair. Strike any clause that lets the adjuster choose your contractor. Florida section 626.854(18) and Colorado section 10-2-417(6)(i)(V) prohibit that power outright. - Checks and money. In Texas, section 4102.104 requires the association to be named on every claim check, and the adjuster may not endorse a check for it. In Colorado, an adjuster who holds claim funds must keep them in a noninterest-bearing escrow or trust account at a federally insured institution. - Settlement authority. Colorado section 10-2-417(6)(j) bars settling without the insured's knowledge and consent. Write that into any contract: no settlement without a board vote. - Estimate deadline. Florida section 626.854(12) requires an itemized written estimate within 60 days of the contract, and lets you cancel if it doesn't arrive, unless the delay was beyond the adjuster's control. - Third-party costs. Florida section 626.854(6) bars charging the association for engineers or other experts unless it agrees in writing after signing. Ask who pays for those in every state.

Approve it like any other contract

The association is the insured, so the contract is an association contract. Put it on the agenda of a noticed board meeting, or a special meeting if the policy deadlines are close. A motion the secretary can copy into the minutes: "Moved that the Board retain [adjuster name], license number [number], and [firm name] as public adjuster for claim [number], date of loss [date], at a fee of [percent or amount] of claim payments received after the date of the contract, excluding the deductible and any amounts paid or committed before that date; that [officer] is authorized to sign the contract; and that no settlement, appraisal demand or release may be signed without a further vote of the Board." After the vote, the insurer gets a copy of the contract or a letter of representation. Keep the association copied on every email. Florida section 626.854(24) gives you a tool here: an adjuster must answer a written or emailed request for claim status with specific information within 14 days. Ask for a monthly written status report in any state.

A sample timeline

Day 0: hail strikes a 40-unit townhome community in Texas. Day 2: claim reported. Day 25: the insurer's adjuster estimates $210,000 for roofs and gutters. Day 40: two roofing bids come in at $295,000 and $310,000. Day 44: the board interviews two public adjusters and gets both fee clauses filled in with dollar figures. Day 50: at a noticed meeting the board votes to hire one at 8 percent, after checking the license with TDI and calling three references. Day 51: contract signed on the TDI-approved form; the 72-hour rescission window closes on day 54. Day 52: the adjuster's letter of representation goes to the insurer. Day 95: the adjuster's itemized estimate goes in at $301,000. Day 130: the insurer revises to $276,000. Day 140: the board votes to accept. The fee is $22,080, and the association nets $253,920 before the deductible, against $210,000 on the first offer.

Mistakes boards make

Signing at the gate. Solicitation peaks in the first week after a storm, and Florida section 626.854(5) limits solicitation to Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Whatever the state, nobody signs until the board has met. Letting one director sign a contract the board never saw. Paying a percentage on money the insurer had already paid or agreed in writing to pay. Florida bans that fee; in Texas and Colorado, negotiate it out. Hiring an adjuster who is also pitching the roof job. Assuming the adjuster replaces the board's own deadlines; the policy duties, including any sworn proof of loss, still belong to the association. Forgetting to calendar the cancellation window. If the insurer won't move even with an adjuster on the file, our guide on using the appraisal clause when an HOA insurance claim is underpaid covers the next step, and our guide on handling an HOA insurance claim after a storm covers the claim from the first call.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Track every request from report to done

Assign maintenance requests to a board member, email vendors a work order with photos, and keep the history. Free to start.