OurHOA
Dues & money

Our HOA's insurance company denied our claim. What should the board do next?

By OurHOA · General information · Revised

What an HOA board does after the insurer denies a claim: read the denial, ask for reconsideration, regulator complaints, and TX, FL and CO deadlines to sue.

Part of the HOA board handbook: vendors, projects and upkeep.

The short answer

A denial letter is the insurer's position, not the last word. Some denials get reversed or narrowed once the association answers the actual reason with evidence, and the rest go to a regulator complaint, mediation where your state offers it, or a lawsuit. The board's job is to find out exactly why the claim was denied, decide whether that reason is about the facts, the policy wording or a missed step, answer it in writing, and keep every deadline alive while it does. Don't let the letter sit until the next quarterly meeting. Rules vary by state, by the policy and by your governing documents. This guide is general education, not legal advice.

Read the denial and sort the reason

Put the letter next to the full policy, with every endorsement, for the policy year of the loss. Ask the agent for a certified copy if you don't have one. The declarations page alone won't show the exclusion the insurer is relying on. The law expects the letter to give a real reason. Texas Insurance Code section 542.056(c) says a rejection notice must state the reasons for it, and section 541.060(a)(3) makes it an unfair settlement practice to fail to promptly give a reasonable explanation of the basis in the policy, in relation to the facts or law, for a denial. Colorado lists the same failure as an unfair claim settlement practice in C.R.S. 10-3-1104(1)(h)(XIV). If the letter only says 'not covered under the policy,' write back and ask for the specific provision and the facts behind it. Then sort the reason into one of three groups, because each one calls for a different answer: A dispute about facts. The adjuster says the roof failed from age, not hail. The leak was 'continuous or repeated seepage' over months, not a sudden pipe burst. The damage happened before the policy started. A dispute about the wording. Everyone agrees on what happened, and the question is whether an exclusion applies, such as whether a wall collapse from hidden rot counts as 'collapse' under the policy. That is a job for coverage counsel, not more photos. A missed step. Late notice, an unanswered request for documents, a missed sworn proof of loss, or no access for an inspection. Some of these can be fixed. Fix them fast.

The steps, in order

1. Log the date the denial arrived and how it came. 2. Protect the evidence. Take dated photos and video, keep samples of the failed shingles, pipe or drywall in a labeled box, and if repairs can't wait, have the contractor document what they find as they open things up. Make urgent repairs to stop further damage, since property policies commonly require that, and keep the invoices. 3. Ask the adjuster in writing for the documents the decision rests on: the field adjuster's report, any engineer's report, the estimate, and the photos. 4. Answer the actual reason. For a cause-of-loss denial, hire your own licensed engineer or roofing consultant, not the contractor who wants the job, and ask for a written opinion on cause and date of loss. For a missed step, cure it and say so in writing. 5. Send a written request for reconsideration with the new evidence attached. Give a date for a response, such as 30 days. 6. Meet with counsel if the insurer stands by the denial, or sooner if the loss is large or a deadline is close. Appraisal usually comes up here, and it is the wrong tool for most denials. Appraisal sets the amount of a covered loss. It doesn't decide whether the loss is covered. Our guide on using the appraisal clause when an HOA insurance claim is underpaid covers the case where the insurer accepted the claim but paid too little.

A reconsideration letter the board can adapt

Have an officer sign it and send it by a method that proves delivery. A starting point to edit: 'Re: Claim [number], policy [number], date of loss [date]. The Association received your letter dated [date] denying this claim on the basis of [provision cited]. The Association disagrees and asks you to reconsider. Enclosed is a report dated [date] from [engineer's name and license number], who inspected the property on [date] and concluded that [one sentence on cause]. Also enclosed are [photos, invoices, weather data, the maintenance log for the roof]. Please review this information and send your written decision within 30 days. If the denial stands, please identify each policy provision and each fact you rely on. The Association does not waive any rights under the policy or applicable law. Please direct all communication about this claim to [name, title, email].' A motion to put the decision on record at the next meeting: 'Move that the board authorize the president to retain [engineer] for a cause-of-loss inspection at a cost not to exceed $[amount], to send a request for reconsideration of claim [number] to [insurer], and to consult association counsel on coverage, with fees not to exceed $[amount] without further board approval.'

Texas, Florida and Colorado rules that shape the next move

Texas. For weather-related property claims, such as hail, wind, flood or a rainstorm, Insurance Code chapter 542A requires written notice to the insurer at least 61 days before filing suit (section 542A.003). The notice must state the acts or omissions behind the claim, the specific amount owed and the attorney fees incurred so far. Chapter 542A doesn't apply to the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association, which has its own rules. Policies often shorten the time to sue, but Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.070 voids any contract clause that sets a period shorter than two years. Read your policy's 'suit against us' condition and calendar the date. Florida. Notice of a new or reopened property claim must reach the insurer within 1 year after the date of loss, and a supplemental claim within 18 months (section 627.70132). Before suing, the association must file a notice of intent to initiate litigation through the Department of Financial Services at least 10 business days ahead, and only after the insurer has made a coverage decision (section 627.70152(3)). After a denial, the insurer has 10 business days to accept coverage, keep denying, or ask to reinspect, and a reinspection gives it 14 more business days to decide. A suit for breach of a property insurance contract must be filed within 5 years from the date of loss (section 95.11(2)(e)). The state's mediation program under section 627.7015 covers commercial residential policies, which section 627.4025(1) defines to include condominium association policies and policies on HOA common elements, but subsection (9) leaves out disputes where the facts about the cause of loss are agreed and the only question is coverage. A cause-of-loss denial can go to mediation. A pure wording fight can't. Colorado. An insurer may not unreasonably delay or deny payment of a claim owed to a first-party claimant, and the definition expressly includes an association (C.R.S. 10-3-1115). If it does, section 10-3-1116 lets the claimant sue for reasonable attorney fees, court costs and two times the covered benefit. Let counsel raise that remedy in the reconsideration letter, not a director in an angry email. Regulator complaints are free. The Texas Department of Insurance tells policyholders who think an insurer treated them unfairly to file a complaint with it, and Florida's Department of Financial Services lists claim disputes and coverage issues among the problems its consumer division handles. A complaint does not extend any of the deadlines above, so keep the calendar running while it is open.

A sample timeline

Day 0: the denial arrives. The president logs it and sends it to the board, the manager and the agent. Day 5: written requests go out for the full policy and the adjuster's file. Day 10: the board votes at a special meeting or by the written consent your bylaws allow to hire an engineer and set a counsel budget. Day 30: the engineer's report is in. Day 35: the reconsideration letter goes out. Day 65: if there is no answer or the denial stands, the board meets with counsel to choose between a regulator complaint, Florida mediation where it fits, and suit. Through all of it, the treasurer keeps a running number for the uncovered cost and tells the board where it would come from: the operating budget, reserves, or a special assessment.

Paying for repairs while the dispute runs

The insurer's denial doesn't change the association's duty to maintain what the declaration makes it responsible for. A roof that leaks into units can't wait six months for a coverage fight. Make the repair and put the invoices in the claim file. A notice to owners that informs without arguing the case: 'The association's insurer has denied the claim for the March roof damage. The board disagrees, has hired an independent engineer and has asked the insurer to reconsider. Repairs to Building C will start on [date] so the leaks stop. We will report the outcome at the [month] meeting.' If the repair has to be funded by an assessment, our guide on levying an insurance deductible assessment after a loss covers the notice and allocation steps, which work much the same way.

Mistakes boards make

Treating the denial as final and quietly absorbing a five-figure loss. Hiring the roofer who wants the replacement job to write the cause-of-loss opinion, which the insurer will discount. Throwing away the damaged materials during repairs. Missing a deadline because nobody read the policy's suit condition or Florida's 1-year notice rule. And ignoring a late-notice denial's lesson: if the leak went unreported for weeks, adopt a reporting policy now. Our guide on responding to a reservation of rights letter from the HOA insurer covers the stage before a denial, when the insurer is still deciding.

Sources

These guides are general education for HOA boards and residents, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by state and by your community's governing documents - check with a professional for your situation.

More from the board handbook

Track every request from report to done

Assign maintenance requests to a board member, email vendors a work order with photos, and keep the history. Free to start.